| Round | Report | Nominees | Team | % of Votes | Match | Note | 
  | 2 | Nominations | Aaron Davey | Melbourne | 24% | Collingwood v Melbourne | Brilliant chase down tackle on Marty Clarke | 
  | Campbell Brown | Hawthorn | 51% | Sydney vs Hawthorn | Courageous smother in front of goal | 
  | Ben McKinley | West Coast | 25% | West Coast vs Port Adelaide | Fantastic chase and tackle | 
  | 3 | Nominations | Eric MacKenzie | West Coast | 9% | St Kilda vs West Coast | Brilliant slide on the goal line to save a goal | 
  | Luke Ball | St Kilda | 82% | St Kilda vs West Coast | Great diving smother on Quinten Lynch | 
  | Nathan Eagleton | Western Bulldogs | 9% | Western Bulldogs vs Richmond | Persistent spoil and tackle | 
  | 4 | Nominations | Luke Hodge | Hawthorn | 21% | Hawthorn vs Port Adelaide | Persistent chase and tackle on Tom Logan | 
  | Eric MacKenzie | West Coast | 35% | West Coast vs Western Bulldogs | Great smother in front of goal | 
  | Ricky Dyson | Essendon | 44% | North Melbourne vs Essendon | Courageous chase and tackle on Drew Petrie | 
  | 5 | Nominations | Shane O'Bree | Collingwood | 10% | Essendon vs Collingwood | Skillful tackle to gain possession and tap on to a teammate. | 
  | Drew Petrie | North Melbourne | 11% | North Melbourne vs Richmond | Courageous chase and tackle | 
  | Lenny Hayes | St Kilda | 79% | Port Adelaide vs St Kilda | Gutsy diving smother | 
  | 6 | Nominations | Joel Macdonald | Brisbane Lions | 17% | Brisbane Lions vs Essendon | Showed courage when executing a spoil | 
  | Martin Mattner | Sydney | 58% | Sydney vs Richmond | Brilliant chase and tackle on Jack Riewoldt | 
  | Luke Hodge | Hawthorn | 25% | Hawthorn vs Carlton | Spoiled, tackled then handballed to team mate | 
  | 7 | Nominations | Daniel Cross | Western Bulldogs | 12% | Adelaide vs Western Bulldogs | Clinical smother on Tyson Edwards | 
  | Jared Rivers | Melbourne | 38% | West Coast vs Melbourne | Extremely courageous attempt to mark | 
  | Bryce Gibbs | Carlton | 50% | Carlton vs Fremantle | Great chase and tackle on Luke McPharlin | 
  | 8 | Nominations | Barry Hall | Sydney | 60% | Sydney vs West Coast | Courageous spoil, then tap to team mate | 
  | Heath Scotland | Carlton | 23% | Collingwood vs Carlton | Phenomenal courage when spoiling a mark | 
  | Nathan Lovett-Murray | Essendon | 17% | St Kilda vs Essendon | Three efforts then tackled causing a turnover | 
  | 9 | Nominations | Mark Austin | Carlton | 24% | Adelaide vs Carlton | Multiple spoils followed by dual tackles | 
  | Michael Osborne | Hawthorn | 16% | Hawthorn vs Melbourne | Effective support and shepherding | 
  | Matt White | Richmond | 60% | Richmond vs Essendon | Fast paced chase and tackle | 
  | 10 | Nominations | Travis Varcoe | Geelong | 67% | Essendon vs Geelong | Double tackle and smother | 
  | Antoni Grover | Fremantle | 20% | Fremantle vs Richmond | Defensive spoil in mid flight | 
  | Daniel Rich | Brisbane Lions | 13% | North Melbourne vs Brisbane Lions | Courageous spoil | 
  | 11 | Nominations | Adam Simpson | North Melbourne | 27% | North Melbourne vs St Kilda | Brilliant smother on Jason Gram | 
  | Scott McMahon | North Melbourne | 54% | North Melbourne vs St Kilda | Courageous smother on Clinton Jones | 
  | Ben McGlynn | Hawthorn | 19% | Hawthorn vs Sydney | Gutsy chase and dive to spoil Michael O'Loughlin | 
  | 12 | Nominations | Darren Glass | West Coast | 25% | Richmond vs West Coast | Diving smother to spoil Tom Hislop | 
  | Brad Green | Melbourne | 43% | Essendon vs Melbourne | Gutsy attempt to spoil the mark | 
  | Dean Solomon | Fremantle | 32% | Fremantle vs Geelong | Courageous dive on the ball | 
  | 13 | Nominations | Dustin Fletcher | Essendon | 12% | Essendon vs Carlton | Spoiled a mark then smothered a kick | 
  | Alwyn Davey | Essendon | 12% | Essendon vs Carlton | Chase-down and tackle | 
  | Patrick Dangerfield | Adelaide | 76% | Adelaide vs Sydney | Smother resulting in a pivotal goal | 
  | 14 | Nominations | Josh Hill | Western Bulldogs | 23% | Western Bulldogs vs Hawthorn | Strong spoil of an overhead, chase and tackle | 
  | Ryan Griffen | Western Bulldogs | 47% | Western Bulldogs vs Hawthorn | Brilliant goal saving smother | 
  | Brett Ebert | Port Adelaide | 30% | Port Adelaide vs Brisbane Lions | Courageous chase and tackle to turnover for a goal | 
  | 15 | Nominations | Nathan Eagleton | Western Bulldogs | 47% | Western Bulldogs vs Collingwood | Courageous interception running back in full flight | 
  | Michael Hurley | Essendon | 30% | Sydney vs Essendon | Gutsy goal saving smother | 
  | Tayte Pears | Essendon | 23% | Sydney vs Essendon | Strong chase down and tackle | 
  | 16 | Nominations | Jake King | Richmond | 22% | Richmond vs North Melbourne | Gutsy double tackle resulting in turnover | 
  | James Frawley | Melbourne | 11% | Geelong vs Melbourne | Strong chase down and tackle | 
  | Jacob Surjan | Port Adelaide | 67% | Port Adelaide vs West Coast | Courageous smother in front of goal | 
  | 17 | Nominations | Tim Ruffles | Fremantle | 27% | Fremantle vs West Coast | Courageous attempt to mark running with the flight | 
  | Nick Riewoldt | St Kilda | 20% | St Kilda vs Western Bulldogs | Great second effort to smother | 
  | Cameron Mooney | Geelong | 53% | Geelong vs Hawthorn | Fearless marking attempt | 
  | 18 | Nominations | Aaron Davey | Melbourne | 37% | Melbourne vs Richmond | Takes on two Richmond opponents and wins possession | 
  | Darren Glass | West Coast | 31% | West Coast vs Essendon | Strong defensive effort and smother to save a certain goal | 
  | Ryan Griffen | Western Bulldogs | 32% | Western Bulldogs vs Fremantle | Great 100m chase and tackle against Fremantle's Grover | 
  | 19 | Nominations | Jarrod Atkinson | Essendon | 19% | Essendon vs Brisbane Lions | Athletic smother and rebound from Essendon's defence | 
  | Dustin Fletcher | Essendon | 24% | Essendon vs Brisbane Lions | Strong spoil, great second effort smother and clearance | 
  | Brett Kirk | Sydney | 57% | Richmond vs Sydney | Won a contested ball, then tapped to teammates advantage | 
  | 20 | Nominations | Lance Franklin | Hawthorn | 10% | Hawthorn vs Adelaide | Fantastic chase and tackle halting an Adelaide attack | 
  | Richard Tambling | Richmond | 32% | Richmond vs Collingwood | Wonderful chase and smother to win possession | 
  | Stephen Milne | St Kilda | 58% | Essendon vs St Kilda | Great smother to create a turnover then goal | 
  | 21 | Nominations | Max Rooke | Geelong | 72% | Western Bulldogs vs Geelong | Multiple strong tackles resulting in a turnover | 
  | Drew Petrie | North Melbourne | 15% | North Melbourne vs St Kilda | Launched himself in the air to spoil | 
  | Jarred Moore | Sydney | 13% | Collingwood vs Sydney | Courageous knock-on resulting in a goal | 
  | 22 | Nominations | Tom Hawkins | Geelong |  | Geelong vs Fremantle | Brilliant smother followed by chase and tackle | 
  |  |  |  |  |  | 
  |  |  |  |  |  |