| Severo Quiñones Court |
| Chief Justice: José Severo Quiñones (1900–1909) |
| 1898–1899: | Maragliano | Hernández Santiago | de Diego Martínez | Figueras | Nieto Abeillé | Roméu Aguayo |
| 1898–1899: | Maragliano | Hernández Santiago | Figueras | Nieto Abeillé | Roméu Aguayo |
| 1899: | Maragliano | Hernández Santiago | Figueras | Nieto Abeillé | Roméu Aguayo | Acosta Quintero |
| 1899: | Maragliano | Hernández Santiago | Figueras | Nieto Abeillé | Roméu Aguayo | Acosta Quintero | Cuchí Arnau |
| 1899: | Hernández Santiago | Figueras | Nieto Abeillé | Roméu Aguayo | Acosta Quintero | Cuchí Arnau | Acuña Aybar |
| 1899–1900: | Hernández Santiago | Figueras | Nieto Abeillé | Morera Martínez |
| 1900–1901: | Hernández Santiago | Figueras | Nieto Abeillé | Sulzbacher |
| 1901: | Hernández Santiago | Figueras | Sulzbacher |
| 1901–1904: | Hernández Santiago | Figueras | Sulzbacher | McLeary |
| 1904–1909: | Hernández Santiago | Figueras | McLeary | Wolf |
| Hernández Santiago Court |
| Chief Justice: José Hernández Santiago (1909–1922) |
| 1909–1910: | Figueras | McLeary | Wolf | del Toro Cuebas |
| 1910–1911: | McLeary | Wolf | del Toro Cuebas |
| 1911–1914: | McLeary | Wolf | del Toro Cuebas | de Aldrey Montolio |
| 1911–1914: | McLeary | Wolf | del Toro Cuebas | de Aldrey Montolio |
| 1914–1922: | Wolf | del Toro Cuebas | de Aldrey Montolio | Hutchinson |
| del Toro Cuebas Court |
| Chief Justice: Emilio del Toro Cuebas (1922–1943) |
| 1922: | Wolf | de Aldrey Montolio | Hutchinson |
| 1922–1927: | Wolf | de Aldrey Montolio | Hutchinson | Franco Soto |
| 1927–1928: | Wolf | de Aldrey Montolio | Hutchinson |
| 1928–1931: | Wolf | de Aldrey Montolio | Hutchinson | Texidor y Alcalá del Olmo |
| 1931–1932: | Wolf | de Aldrey Montolio | Hutchinson |
| 1932–1935: | Wolf | de Aldrey Montolio | Hutchinson | Córdova Dávila |
| 1935–1936: | Wolf | Hutchinson | Córdova Dávila |
| 1936–1938: | Wolf | Hutchinson | Córdova Dávila | Travieso |
| 1938: | Wolf | Hutchinson | Travieso |
| 1938–1940: | Wolf | Hutchinson | Travieso | de Jesús Sánchez |
| 1940–1941: | Travieso | de Jesús Sánchez |
| 1941–1942: | Travieso | de Jesús Sánchez | Todd Borrás |
| 1942–1943: | Travieso | de Jesús Sánchez | Todd Borrás | Snyder |
| Travieso Court |
| Chief Justice: Martín Travieso (1944–1948) |
| 1944–1945: | de Jesús Sánchez | Todd Borrás | Snyder |
| 1945–1946: | de Jesús Sánchez | Todd Borrás | Snyder | Córdova Díaz |
| 1946–1947: | de Jesús Sánchez | Todd Borrás | Snyder |
| 1947–1948: | de Jesús Sánchez | Todd Borrás | Snyder | Marrero Ríos |
| de Jesús Sánchez Court |
| Chief Justice: Angel de Jesús Sánchez (1948–1951) |
| 1948–1951: | Todd Borrás | Snyder | Marrero Ríos | Negrón Fernández |
| Todd Borrás Court |
| Chief Justice: Roberto Todd Borrás (1951–1952) |
| 1951–1952: | Snyder | Marrero Ríos | Negrón Fernández |
| 1952: | Snyder | Marrero Ríos | Negrón Fernández | Ortiz Ortiz | Sifre Dávila | Pérez Pimentel |
| Snyder Court |
| Chief Justice: A. Cecil Snyder (1953–1957) |
| 1953–1954: | Marrero Ríos | Negrón Fernández | Ortiz Ortiz | Sifre Dávila | Pérez Pimentel | Belaval Maldonado |
| 1954–1955: | Marrero Ríos | Negrón Fernández | Sifre Dávila | Pérez Pimentel | Belaval Maldonado |
| 1955–1957: | Marrero Ríos | Negrón Fernández | Sifre Dávila | Pérez Pimentel | Belaval Maldonado | Saldaña Amadeo |
| 1957: | Negrón Fernández | Sifre Dávila | Pérez Pimentel | Belaval Maldonado | Saldaña Amadeo |
| Sifre Dávila Court |
| Chief Justice: Jaime Sifre Dávila (1957) |
| 1957: | Negrón Fernández | Pérez Pimentel | Belaval Maldonado | Saldaña Amadeo |
| Negrón Fernández Court |
| Chief Justice: Luis Negrón Fernández (1957–1972) |
| 1957–1961: | Pérez Pimentel | Belaval Maldonado | Saldaña Amadeo | Hernández Matos | Santana Becerra | Serrano Geyls |
| 1961: | Pérez Pimentel | Belaval Maldonado | Hernández Matos | Santana Becerra | Serrano Geyls | Blanco Lugo |
| 1961–1962: | Pérez Pimentel | Belaval Maldonado | Hernández Matos | Santana Becerra | Serrano Geyls | Blanco Lugo | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila |
| 1962: | Pérez Pimentel | Belaval Maldonado | Hernández Matos | Santana Becerra | Blanco Lugo | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila |
| 1962–1968: | Pérez Pimentel | Belaval Maldonado | Hernández Matos | Santana Becerra | Blanco Lugo | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Ramírez Bages |
| 1968: | Pérez Pimentel | Hernández Matos | Santana Becerra | Blanco Lugo | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Ramírez Bages |
| 1968–1970: | Pérez Pimentel | Hernández Matos | Santana Becerra | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Ramírez Bages | Torres Rigual | Blanco Lugo |
| 1970–1971: | Pérez Pimentel | Hernández Matos | Santana Becerra | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Ramírez Bages | Torres Rigual | Martínez Muñoz |
| 1971: | Pérez Pimentel | Hernández Matos | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Ramírez Bages | Torres Rigual | Martínez Muñoz |
| 1971–1972: | Pérez Pimentel | Hernández Matos | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Ramírez Bages | Torres Rigual | Martínez Muñoz | Martín Taboas |
| Pérez Pimentel Court |
| Chief Justice: Pedro Pérez Pimentel (1973–1974) |
| 1973: | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Torres Rigual | Martínez Muñoz | Martín Taboas | Cadilla Ginorio |
| 1973: | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Torres Rigual | Martínez Muñoz | Martín Taboas | Cadilla Ginorio | Díaz Cruz |
| 1973: | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Torres Rigual | Martínez Muñoz | Martín Taboas | Cadilla Ginorio | Díaz Cruz | Irizarry Yunqué |
| 1973–1974: | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Torres Rigual | Martín Taboas | Cadilla Ginorio | Díaz Cruz | Irizarry Yunqué |
| Trías Monge Court |
| Chief Justice: José Trías Monge (1974–1985) |
| 1974: | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Torres Rigual | Martín Taboas | Cadilla Ginorio | Díaz Cruz | Irizarry Yunqué |
| 1974–1975: | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Torres Rigual | Martín Taboas | Cadilla Ginorio | Díaz Cruz | Irizarry Yunqué | Negrón García |
| 1975–1981: | Rigau Gaztambide | Dávila Dávila | Torres Rigual | Martín Taboas | Díaz Cruz | Irizarry Yunqué | Negrón García |
| 1981–1982: | Dávila Dávila | Torres Rigual | Martín Taboas | Díaz Cruz | Irizarry Yunqué | Negrón García |
| 1982: | Dávila Dávila | Torres Rigual | Díaz Cruz | Irizarry Yunqué | Negrón García |
| 1982–1984: | Dávila Dávila | Torres Rigual | Díaz Cruz | Irizarry Yunqué | Negrón García | Rebollo López |
| 1984–1985: | Torres Rigual | Irizarry Yunqué | Negrón García | Rebollo López |
| 1985: | Irizarry Yunqué | Negrón García | Rebollo López |
| 1985: | Irizarry Yunqué | Negrón García | Rebollo López | Ortiz Gustafson |
| 1985: | Irizarry Yunqué | Negrón García | Rebollo López| Ortiz Gustafson | Naveira Merly | Hernández Denton |
| Pons Núñez Court |
| Chief Justice: Víctor Pons Núñez (1985–1992) |
| 1985–1986: | Irizarry Yunqué | Negrón García | Rebollo López | Ortiz Gustafson | Naveira Merly | Hernández Denton |
| 1986–1990: | Negrón García | Rebollo López | Ortiz Gustafson | Naveira Merly | Hernández Denton | Alonso Alonso |
| 1990–1992: | Negrón García | Rebollo López | Naveira Merly | Hernández Denton | Alonso Alonso | Andréu García |
| Andréu García Court |
| Chief Justice: José Andréu García (1992–2003) |
| 1992: | Negrón García | Rebollo López| Naveira Merly | Hernández Denton | Alonso Alonso |
| 1992–1995: | Negrón García | Rebollo López | Naveira Merly | Hernández Denton | Alonso Alonso | Fuster Berlingeri |
| 1995–2000: | Negrón García | Rebollo López | Naveira Merly | Hernández Denton | Fuster Berlingeri | Corrada del Río |
| 2000–2003: | Rebollo López | Naveira Merly | Hernández Denton | Fuster Berlingeri | Corrada del Río | Rivera Pérez |
| Naveira Merly Court |
| Chief Justice: Miriam Naveira Merly (2003–2004) |
| 2003–2004: | Rebollo López | Hernández Denton | Fuster Berlingeri | Corrada del Río | Rivera Pérez |
| 2004: | Rebollo López | Hernández Denton | Fuster Berlingeri | Corrada del Río | Rivera Pérez | Fiol Matta |
| Hernández Denton Court |
| Chief Justice: Federico Hernández Denton (2004–2014) |
| 2004: | Rebollo López | Fuster Berlingeri | Corrada del Río | Rivera Pérez | Fiol Matta |
| 2004–2005: | Rebollo López | Fuster Berlingeri | Corrada del Río | Rivera Pérez | Fiol Matta | Rodríguez Rodríguez |
| 2005–2007: | Rebollo López | Fuster Berlingeri | Rivera Pérez | Fiol Matta | Rodríguez Rodríguez |
| 2007–2008: | Rebollo López | Rivera Pérez | Fiol Matta | Rodríguez Rodríguez |
| 2008–2009: | Rivera Pérez | Fiol Matta | Rodríguez Rodríguez |
| 2009–2010: | Rivera Pérez | Fiol Matta | Rodríguez Rodríguez | Martínez Torres | Pabón Charneco | Kolthoff Caraballo |
| 2010–2014: | Fiol Matta | Rodríguez Rodríguez | Martínez Torres | Pabón Charneco | Kolthoff Caraballo | Rivera García | Feliberti Cintrón | Estrella Martínez |
| Fiol Matta Court |
| Chief Justice: Liana Fiol Matta (2014–2016) |
| 2014: | Rodríguez Rodríguez | Martínez Torres | Pabón Charneco | Kolthoff Caraballo | Rivera García | Feliberti Cintrón | Estrella Martínez |
| 2014–2016: | Rodríguez Rodríguez | Martínez Torres | Pabón Charneco | Kolthoff Caraballo | Rivera García | Feliberti Cintrón | Estrella Martínez | Oronoz Rodríguez |
| Oronoz Rodríguez Court |
| Chief Justice: Maite Oronoz Rodríguez (2016–) |
| 2016: | Rodríguez Rodríguez | Martínez Torres | Pabón Charneco | Kolthoff Caraballo | Rivera García | Feliberti Cintrón | Estrella Martínez |
| 2016: | Rodríguez Rodríguez | Martínez Torres | Pabón Charneco | Kolthoff Caraballo | Rivera García | Feliberti Cintrón | Estrella Martínez | Colón-Pérez |
| 2020: | Martínez Torres | Pabón Charneco | Kolthoff Caraballo | Rivera García | Feliberti Cintrón | Estrella Martínez | Colón-Pérez |
| 2025: | Martínez Torres | Pabón Charneco | Kolthoff Caraballo | Rivera García | Feliberti Cintrón | Estrella Martínez | Colón-Pérez | Candelario López | Rivera Pérez |