| School | Nickname | City | State | Other affiliations |
| Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences | Panthers | Albany | New York | Yankee Small College Conference |
| Andrews University | Cardinals | Berrien Springs | Michigan | |
| The Apprentice School | Builders | Newport News | Virginia | New South Athletic Conference |
| Atlantis University | Atlanteans | Miami | Florida | New South Athletic Conference |
| Bay Path University | Wildcats | Longmeadow | Massachusetts | |
| Beacon College | Blazers | Leesburg | Florida | New South Athletic Conference |
| Berkeley College | Knights | Woodland Park and New York | New Jersey and New York | Hudson Valley Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
| Bloomfield College | Bears | Bloomfield | New Jersey | |
| Bryant & Stratton College, Albany | Bobcats | Albany | New York | |
| Bryant & Stratton College, Buffalo | Bobcats | Buffalo | New York | |
| Bryant & Stratton College, Ohio | Bobcats | Solon | Ohio | Ohio Community College Athletic Conference (NJCAA) |
| Bryant & Stratton College, Rochester | Bobcats | Rochester | New York | |
| Bryant & Stratton College, Syracuse | Bobcats | Syracuse | New York | |
| Bucks County Community College | Centurions | Newtown | Pennsylvania | Eastern Pennsylvania Athletic Conference (NJCAA)
Eastern States Athletic Conference |
| California Miramar University | Fighting Falcons | La Puente | California | |
| Carlow University | Celtics | Pittsburgh | Pennsylvania | Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference (NCAA Division III) |
| Central Maine Community College | Mustangs | Auburn | Maine | Yankee Small College Conference |
| Central Penn College | Knights | Summerdale | Pennsylvania | Eastern States Athletic Conference |
| Christendom College | Crusaders | Front Royal | Virginia | Eastern States Athletic Conference |
| University of Cincinnati Clermont College | Cougars | Batavia | Ohio | |
| Colorado Mountain College – Leadville | Eagles | Leadville | Colorado | NJCAA |
| Crown College | Royal Crusaders | Powell | Tennessee | |
| Denmark Technical College | Panthers | Denmark | South Carolina | Carolinas Junior College Conference (NJCAA) |
| Diné College | Warriors | Tsaile | Arizona | |
| East–West University | Phantoms | Chicago | Illinois | |
| Five Towns College | Sounds | Dix Hills | New York | Hudson Valley Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
| Florida National University | Conquistadors | Hialeah | Florida | Continental Athletic Conference (NAIA) |
| Great Bay Community College | Herons | Portsmouth | New Hampshire | Yankee Small College Conference |
| Hampshire College | Black Sheep | Amherst | Massachusetts | Yankee Small College Conference |
| John Melvin Christian College (provisional member) | Mohawks | Pensacola | Florida | |
| John Melvin Christian College – Winter Park (exploratory member) | Mangos | Winter Park | Florida | |
| John Melvin University (provisional member) | Millers | Crowley | Louisiana | |
| Kennebec Valley Community College | | Fairfield and Hinckley | Maine | |
| Kent State University Tuscarawas | Golden Eagles | New Philadelphia | Ohio | |
| Lyon College | Scots | Batesville | Arkansas | St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (NCAA Division III) |
| University of Maine at Augusta | Moose | Augusta | Maine | Yankee Small College Conference |
| University of Maine at Fort Kent | Bengals | Fort Kent | Maine | |
| Manor College | Blue Jays | Jenkintown | Pennsylvania | Eastern States Athletic Conference |
| Miami University Hamilton | Harriers | Hamilton | Ohio | |
| Miami University Middletown | Thunderhawks | Middletown | Ohio | |
| Mid-Atlantic Christian University | Mustangs | Elizabeth City | North Carolina | New South Athletic Conference |
| Navajo Technical University | Skyhawks | Crownpoint | New Mexico | |
| NHTI, Concord's Community College | Lynx | Concord | New Hampshire | Yankee Small College Conference |
| North American University | Stallions | Stafford | Texas | Red River Athletic Conference (NAIA) |
| Paul Quinn College | Tigers | Dallas | Texas | Red River Athletic Conference (NAIA) |
| Paul Smith's College | Bobcats | Paul Smiths | New York | Yankee Small College Conference |
| Penn State Beaver | Nittany Lions | Monaca | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State DuBois | Nittany Lions | DuBois | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Fayette, The Eberly Campus | Nittany Lions | Uniontown | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Greater Allegheny | Nittany Lions | McKeesport | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Hazleton | Nittany Lions | Hazleton | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Lehigh Valley | Nittany Lions | Center Valley | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Mont Alto | Nittany Lions | Mont Alto | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State New Kensington | Nittany Lions | New Kensington | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Schuylkill | Nittany Lions | Schuylkill Haven | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Scranton | Nittany Lions | Dunmore | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Shenango | Nittany Lions | Sharon | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State Wilkes-Barre | Nittany Lions | Back Mountain | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Penn State York | Nittany Lions | York | Pennsylvania | Penn State University Athletic Conference |
| Quincy College | Granite | Quincy | Massachusetts | Massachusetts Community College Athletic Association (NJCAA) |
| Salem University | Tigers | Salem | West Virginia | Independent (NCAA Division II) |
| Shaw University | Bears | Raleigh | North Carolina | Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association (NCAA Division II) |
| Southeastern Illinois College | Falcons | Harrisburg | Illinois | NJCAA Division I |
| Southern California Leadership University (provisional member) | Rhinos | Westminster | California | |
| Southern Maine Community College | SeaWolves | South Portland | Maine | Yankee Small College Conference |
| Southwestern Adventist University | Knights | Keene | Texas | NCCAA Division II |
| Stanton University | Fighting Elks | Garden Grove | California | California Pacific Conference (NAIA) |
| SUNY Environmental Science and Forestry | Mighty Oaks | Syracuse | New York | Hudson Valley Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
| Trinity College of Florida | Tigers | Trinity | Florida | |
| United International College | Eagle Rays | Miramar | Florida | |
| United States Sports Academy | Eagles | Daphne | Alabama | |
| Vaughn College | Warriors | Flushing | New York | |
| Vermont State Randolph (Vermont Tech) | Green Knights | Randolph Center | Vermont | Yankee Small College Conference |
| Villa Maria College | Vikings | Buffalo | New York | Hudson Valley Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
| Virginia State University | Trojans | Ettrick | Virginia | Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association (NCAA Division II) |
| Washington County Community College | Golden Eagles | Calais | Maine | |
| Williamson College of the Trades | Mechanics | Media | Pennsylvania | Eastern States Athletic Conference |
| Word of Life Bible Institute/Davis College | Huskies | Pottersville | New York | Hudson Valley Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
| Wright State University-Lake Campus | Lakers | Celina | Ohio | |
| York County Community College | Hawks | Wells | Maine | Yankee Small College Conference |