| Year | Category | Nominee(s) | Result |
| 2009 [1] | Outstanding Studio Show, Daily | MLB Tonight | Nominated |
| Outstanding Studio Show, Weekly | Studio 42 with Bob Costas | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Host | Bob Costas | Won |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Analyst | Al Leiter | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Sports Event Analyst | Jim Kaat | Nominated |
| Outstanding Edited Sports Special | Incident At Candlestick | Nominated |
| Josh Hamilton: Resurrecting the Dream | Nominated |
| Outstanding Graphic Design | MLB Tonight | Won |
| Outstanding Production Design/Art Direction | MLB Tonight | Won |
| Outstanding Technical Team Studio | MLB Tonight | Won |
| The George Wensel Technical Achievement Award | Ballpark Cam | Nominated |
| Enhanced Digital Recreation / Reenactment | Nominated |
| 2010 [2] | Outstanding Studio Show, Daily | MLB Tonight | Won |
| Outstanding Studio Show, Weekly | Studio 42 with Bob Costas | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Host | Bob Costas | Won |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Play-by-Play | Bob Costas | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Analyst | Harold Reynolds | Nominated |
| Outstanding Graphic Design | MLB Network Studio Graphics | Nominated |
| Outstanding Technical Team Studio | MLB Tonight | Nominated |
| The George Wensel Technical Achievement Award | Ballpark Cam | Nominated |
| 2011 [3][4] | Outstanding Studio Show, Daily | MLB Tonight | Won |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Host | Bob Costas | Won |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Analyst | Al Leiter | Nominated |
| Harold Reynolds | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Sports Event Analyst | Jim Kaat | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Promotional Announcement - Institutional | All in One Place (All in One Place;[5] Timeline) | Nominated |
| Outstanding Technical Team Studio | MLB Tonight | Won |
| The George Wensel Technical Achievement Award | The DIAMOND Platform | Nominated |
| 2012 [6][7] | Outstanding Studio Show, Daily | MLB Tonight | Won |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Analyst | Billy Ripken | Nominated |
| Harold Reynolds | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Sports Event Analyst | Jim Kaat | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Sports Reporter | Tom Verducci | Won |
| Outstanding Open/Tease | MLB Network Division Series (The Scrapbook) [8] | Nominated |
| Outstanding Graphic Design | MLB Network Division Series (The Scrapbook) | Won |
| Outstanding Live Event Audio/Sound | MLB Network Spring Training Game - Indians vs. Diamondbacks All Audio | Nominated |
| Outstanding Technical Team Studio | MLB Tonight | Nominated |
| 2013 [9][10] | Outstanding Studio Show, Daily | MLB Tonight | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Host | Bob Costas | Won |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Play-by-Play | Bob Costas | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Analyst | Al Leiter | Nominated |
| Harold Reynolds | Won |
| Tom Verducci | Won |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Sports Reporter | Tom Verducci | Nominated |
| Outstanding Open/Tease | MLB Network Division Series (A Field of Dreamers) [11] | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Promotional Announcement - Institutional | MLB Network Prime Time Line Up (Here’s To Us) [12] | Nominated |
| Outstanding Live Event Graphic Design | Intentional Talk | Nominated |
| Outstanding Post-Produced Graphic Design | MLB Tonight | Won |
| Outstanding Production Design/Art Direction | MLB Network Division Series (A Field of Dreamers) | Nominated |
| Outstanding Technical Team Studio | MLB Tonight | Won |
| The George Wensel Technical Achievement Award | MLB Network Division Series (A Field of Dreamers) | Nominated |
| 2014 [13][14] | Outstanding Studio Show, Daily | MLB Tonight | Won |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Host | Bob Costas | Nominated |
| Matt Vasgersian | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Play-by-Play | Bob Costas | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Analyst | Harold Reynolds | Won |
| Tom Verducci | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Sports Event Analyst | Harold Reynolds | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Sports Reporter | Ken Rosenthal | Won |
| Tom Verducci | Nominated |
| Outstanding Edited Sports Special | Mr. Baseball: Bob Uecker | Nominated |
| Outstanding Open/Tease | 2014 Baseball Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony (Hall of Heroes) [15] | Nominated |
| Outstanding Sports Promotional Announcement | Monuments [16] | Nominated |
| Outstanding Long Form Editing | The Third Team | Nominated |
| Outstanding Music Composition/Direction/Lyrics | 2014 Baseball Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony (Hall of Heroes) | Nominated |
| Outstanding Production Design/Art Direction | 2014 Baseball Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony (Hall of Heroes) | Won |
| Outstanding Technical Team Studio | MLB Tonight | Nominated |
| 2015 [17][18] | Outstanding Studio Show, Daily | MLB Tonight | Won |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Host | Bob Costas | Won |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Studio Analyst | Al Leiter | Nominated |
| Harold Reynolds | Nominated |
| Billy Ripken | Won |
| Outstanding Sports Personality, Sports Reporter | Ken Rosenthal | Won |
| Tom Verducci | Nominated |
| Outstanding Post-Produced Graphic Design | MLB Central | Nominated |
| Outstanding Studio Design/Art Direction | Studio 21 | Nominated |
| Outstanding Production Design/Art Direction | MLB Network Divisional Playoffs (Little Big Men) [19] | Nominated |
| Outstanding Technical Team Studio | MLB Tonight | Nominated |
| The George Wensel Technical Achievement Award | MLB Network Showcase - Statcast Powered by Amazon Web Services | Nominated |