| Round  |  Report  |  Nominees  |  Team  |  % of Votes  |  Match  |  Note  | 
  | 2  |  Nominations  |  Aaron Davey  |  Melbourne  |  24%  |  Collingwood v Melbourne  |  Brilliant chase down tackle on Marty Clarke  | 
  | Campbell Brown  |  Hawthorn  |  51%  |  Sydney vs Hawthorn  |  Courageous smother in front of goal  | 
  | Ben McKinley  |  West Coast  |  25%  |  West Coast vs Port Adelaide  |  Fantastic chase and tackle  | 
  | 3  |  Nominations  |  Eric MacKenzie  |  West Coast  |  9%  |  St Kilda vs West Coast  |  Brilliant slide on the goal line to save a goal  | 
  | Luke Ball  |  St Kilda  |  82%  |  St Kilda vs West Coast  |  Great diving smother on Quinten Lynch  | 
  | Nathan Eagleton  |  Western Bulldogs  |  9%  |  Western Bulldogs vs Richmond  |  Persistent spoil and tackle  | 
  | 4  |  Nominations  |  Luke Hodge  |  Hawthorn  |  21%  |  Hawthorn vs Port Adelaide  |  Persistent chase and tackle on Tom Logan  | 
  | Eric MacKenzie  |  West Coast  |  35%  |  West Coast vs Western Bulldogs  |  Great smother in front of goal  | 
  | Ricky Dyson  |  Essendon  |  44%  |  North Melbourne vs Essendon  |  Courageous chase and tackle on Drew Petrie  | 
  | 5  |  Nominations  |  Shane O'Bree  |  Collingwood  |  10%  |  Essendon vs Collingwood  |  Skillful tackle to gain possession and tap on to a teammate.  | 
  | Drew Petrie  |  North Melbourne  |  11%  |  North Melbourne vs Richmond  |  Courageous chase and tackle  | 
  | Lenny Hayes  |  St Kilda  |  79%  |  Port Adelaide vs St Kilda  |  Gutsy diving smother  | 
  | 6  |  Nominations  |  Joel Macdonald  |  Brisbane Lions  |  17%  |  Brisbane Lions vs Essendon  |  Showed courage when executing a spoil  | 
  | Martin Mattner  |  Sydney  |  58%  |  Sydney vs Richmond  |  Brilliant chase and tackle on Jack Riewoldt  | 
  | Luke Hodge  |  Hawthorn  |  25%  |  Hawthorn vs Carlton  |  Spoiled, tackled then handballed to team mate  | 
  | 7  |  Nominations  |  Daniel Cross  |  Western Bulldogs  |  12%  |  Adelaide vs Western Bulldogs  |  Clinical smother on Tyson Edwards  | 
  | Jared Rivers  |  Melbourne  |  38%  |  West Coast vs Melbourne  |  Extremely courageous attempt to mark  | 
  | Bryce Gibbs  |  Carlton  |  50%  |  Carlton vs Fremantle  |  Great chase and tackle on Luke McPharlin  | 
  | 8  |  Nominations  |  Barry Hall  |  Sydney  |  60%  |  Sydney vs West Coast  |  Courageous spoil, then tap to team mate  | 
  | Heath Scotland  |  Carlton  |  23%  |  Collingwood vs Carlton  |  Phenomenal courage when spoiling a mark  | 
  | Nathan Lovett-Murray  |  Essendon  |  17%  |  St Kilda vs Essendon  |  Three efforts then tackled causing a turnover  | 
  | 9  |  Nominations  |  Mark Austin  |  Carlton  |  24%  |  Adelaide vs Carlton  |  Multiple spoils followed by dual tackles  | 
  | Michael Osborne  |  Hawthorn  |  16%  |  Hawthorn vs Melbourne  |  Effective support and shepherding  | 
  | Matt White  |  Richmond  |  60%  |  Richmond vs Essendon  |  Fast paced chase and tackle  | 
  | 10  |  Nominations  |  Travis Varcoe  |  Geelong  |  67%  |  Essendon vs Geelong  |  Double tackle and smother  | 
  | Antoni Grover  |  Fremantle  |  20%  |  Fremantle vs Richmond  |  Defensive spoil in mid flight  | 
  | Daniel Rich  |  Brisbane Lions  |  13%  |  North Melbourne vs Brisbane Lions  |  Courageous spoil  | 
  | 11  |  Nominations  |  Adam Simpson  |  North Melbourne  |  27%  |  North Melbourne vs St Kilda  |  Brilliant smother on Jason Gram  | 
  | Scott McMahon  |  North Melbourne  |  54%  |  North Melbourne vs St Kilda  |  Courageous smother on Clinton Jones  | 
  | Ben McGlynn  |  Hawthorn  |  19%  |  Hawthorn vs Sydney  |  Gutsy chase and dive to spoil Michael O'Loughlin  | 
  | 12  |  Nominations  |  Darren Glass  |  West Coast  |  25%  |  Richmond vs West Coast  |  Diving smother to spoil Tom Hislop  | 
  | Brad Green  |  Melbourne  |  43%  |  Essendon vs Melbourne  |  Gutsy attempt to spoil the mark  | 
  | Dean Solomon  |  Fremantle  |  32%  |  Fremantle vs Geelong  |  Courageous dive on the ball  | 
  | 13  |  Nominations  |  Dustin Fletcher  |  Essendon  |  12%  |  Essendon vs Carlton  |  Spoiled a mark then smothered a kick  | 
  | Alwyn Davey  |  Essendon  |  12%  |  Essendon vs Carlton  |  Chase-down and tackle  | 
  | Patrick Dangerfield  |  Adelaide  |  76%  |  Adelaide vs Sydney  |  Smother resulting in a pivotal goal  | 
  | 14  |  Nominations  |  Josh Hill  |  Western Bulldogs  |  23%  |  Western Bulldogs vs Hawthorn  |  Strong spoil of an overhead, chase and tackle  | 
  | Ryan Griffen  |  Western Bulldogs  |  47%  |  Western Bulldogs vs Hawthorn  |  Brilliant goal saving smother  | 
  | Brett Ebert  |  Port Adelaide  |  30%  |  Port Adelaide vs Brisbane Lions  |  Courageous chase and tackle to turnover for a goal  | 
  | 15  |  Nominations  |  Nathan Eagleton  |  Western Bulldogs  |  47%  |  Western Bulldogs vs Collingwood  |  Courageous interception running back in full flight  | 
  | Michael Hurley  |  Essendon  |  30%  |  Sydney vs Essendon  |  Gutsy goal saving smother  | 
  | Tayte Pears  |  Essendon  |  23%  |  Sydney vs Essendon  |  Strong chase down and tackle  | 
  | 16  |  Nominations  |  Jake King  |  Richmond  |  22%  |  Richmond vs North Melbourne  |  Gutsy double tackle resulting in turnover  | 
  | James Frawley  |  Melbourne  |  11%  |  Geelong vs Melbourne  |  Strong chase down and tackle  | 
  | Jacob Surjan  |  Port Adelaide  |  67%  |  Port Adelaide vs West Coast  |  Courageous smother in front of goal  | 
  | 17  |  Nominations  |  Tim Ruffles  |  Fremantle  |  27%  |  Fremantle vs West Coast  |  Courageous attempt to mark running with the flight  | 
  | Nick Riewoldt  |  St Kilda  |  20%  |  St Kilda vs Western Bulldogs  |  Great second effort to smother  | 
  | Cameron Mooney  |  Geelong  |  53%  |  Geelong vs Hawthorn  |  Fearless marking attempt  | 
  | 18  |  Nominations  |  Aaron Davey  |  Melbourne  |  37%  |  Melbourne vs Richmond  |  Takes on two Richmond opponents and wins possession  | 
  | Darren Glass  |  West Coast  |  31%  |  West Coast vs Essendon  |  Strong defensive effort and smother to save a certain goal  | 
  | Ryan Griffen  |  Western Bulldogs  |  32%  |  Western Bulldogs vs Fremantle  |  Great 100m chase and tackle against Fremantle's Grover  | 
  | 19  |  Nominations  |  Jarrod Atkinson  |  Essendon  |  19%  |  Essendon vs Brisbane Lions  |  Athletic smother and rebound from Essendon's defence  | 
  | Dustin Fletcher  |  Essendon  |  24%  |  Essendon vs Brisbane Lions  |  Strong spoil, great second effort smother and clearance  | 
  | Brett Kirk  |  Sydney  |  57%  |  Richmond vs Sydney  |  Won a contested ball, then tapped to teammates advantage  | 
  | 20  |  Nominations  |  Lance Franklin  |  Hawthorn  |  10%  |  Hawthorn vs Adelaide  |  Fantastic chase and tackle halting an Adelaide attack  | 
  | Richard Tambling  |  Richmond  |  32%  |  Richmond vs Collingwood  |  Wonderful chase and smother to win possession  | 
  | Stephen Milne  |  St Kilda  |  58%  |  Essendon vs St Kilda  |  Great smother to create a turnover then goal  | 
  | 21  |  Nominations  |  Max Rooke  |  Geelong  |  72%  |  Western Bulldogs vs Geelong  |  Multiple strong tackles resulting in a turnover  | 
  | Drew Petrie  |  North Melbourne  |  15%  |  North Melbourne vs St Kilda  |  Launched himself in the air to spoil  | 
  | Jarred Moore  |  Sydney  |  13%  |  Collingwood vs Sydney  |  Courageous knock-on resulting in a goal  | 
  | 22  |  Nominations  |  Tom Hawkins  |  Geelong  |    |  Geelong vs Fremantle  |  Brilliant smother followed by chase and tackle  | 
  |   |    |    |    |    | 
  |   |    |    |    |    |