| Category | Winner | Nominated |
| Bisexual Literature | Brent Hartinger, Split Screen | |
| Gay Debut Fiction | Christopher Kelly, A Push and a Shove | |
| Gay Fiction | André Aciman, Call Me By Your Name | |
| Gay Memoir/Biography | Kevin Sessums, Mississippi Sissy | |
| Gay Mystery | Greg Herren, Murder in the Rue Chartres | |
| Gay Romance | Michael Thomas Ford, Changing Tides | - Robin Reardon, A Secret Edge
- Frederick Smith, Right Side of the Wrong Bed
- Seth Rudetsky, Broadway Nights
- Robert Taylor, A Few Hints and Clews
|
| Lesbian Debut Fiction | Aoibheann Sweeney, Among Other Things, I've Taken Up Smoking | |
| Lesbian Fiction | Ali Liebegott, The IHOP Papers | |
| Lesbian Memoir/Biography | Nicola Griffith, And Now We Are Going to Have a Party | |
| Lesbian Mystery | Gabrielle Goldsby, Wall of Silence | - Ellen Hart, Mortal Groove
- Gerri Hill, In the Name of the Father
- Jennifer L. Jordan, Selective Memory
- Ursula Steck, Laura’s War
|
| Lesbian Romance | KG MacGregor, Out of Love | |
| LGBT Anthology | Richard Labonté and Lawrence Schimel, First Person Queer | |
| LGBT Children's/Young Adult | Perry Moore, Hero | |
| LGBT Drama | Steve Susoyev and George Birimisa, eds., Return to the Caffe Cino | |
| LGBT Erotica | Simon Sheppard, Homosex: 60 Years of Gay Erotica | - Victoria Brownworth and Judith M. Redding, The Golden Age of Lesbian Erotica
- J. D. Glass, Red Light
- William Maltese and Wayne Gunn, Ardennian Boy
- Lawrence Schimel, The Mammoth Book of New Gay Erotica
- Fiona Zedde, Every Dark Desire
|
| LGBT Non-Fiction | Michael S. Sherry, Gay Artists in Modern American Culture | - Sharon Marcus, Between Women
- Toni Mirosevich, Pink Harvest
- Michael Rowe, Other Men’s Sons
- David Valentine, Imagining Transgender
|
| LGBT Poetry | Henri Cole, Blackbird and Wolf | |
| LGBT Science Fiction/Fantasy/Horror | Lee Thomas, The Dust of Wonderland | |
| LGBT Studies | Sharon Marcus, Between Women | |
| Transgender Literature | Cris Beam, ed., Transparent | - LeeRay M. Costa, Male Bodies, Women’s Souls
- Eli Clare, The Marrow’s Telling
- Aaron Raz Link and Hilda Raz, What Becomes You
- Matt Bernstein Sycamore, Nobody Passes
|
| Arts & Culture | Matthew Hays, The View from Here: Conversations with Gay and Lesbian Filmmakers | |