| Name | Original chapter | Notability | References |
| Kenny Albert | New York University | Sportscaster | |
| Bill Brown | | Professional football player; Pro Bowl running back, Minnesota Vikings | |
| Brandon Brown | Coastal Carolina University | NASCAR driver | |
| Hubert A. Caldwell | | Olympic crew, 1928 gold medalist | |
| Sean Casey | University of Richmond | Professional baseball player; first baseman, Boston Red Sox | [19] |
| Chris Chike | | eSports competitor; former #1 ranked Guitar Hero player in the world; 2017 DanceDanceRevolution world champion and current #2 ranked player in the world | |
| Bill Cubit | | Head football coach, Western Michigan University | |
| Bill Doba | | Former head football coach, Washington State University | |
| John Fina | | Professional football player; tackle, Buffalo Bills | [19] |
| Richard J. Gannon | University of Delaware | Professional football player; quarterback, Oakland Raiders, NFL MVP 2002 | [19] |
| Orel Hershiser | Bowling Green State University | Professional baseball player; pitcher, Los Angeles Dodgers, Cy Young Award Winner, 1988, World Series Champion | [19] |
| Tom Hicks | University of Texas at Austin | Former owner of the Dallas Stars, Liverpool F.C. and Texas Rangers | [19] |
| Bobby Hurley | Duke University | Former NBA player, NCAA coach | |
| Nate Hybl | University of Oklahoma | Quarterback, 2002 Rose Bowl MVP | |
| James Johnson | | Professional basketball player; Miami Heat | [19] |
| Gene Keady | | Former head coach, Purdue University Men's Basketball | |
| Don Laz | | Olympic pole vaulter, 1952 Summer Olympics | |
| Bob Lilly | Texas Christian University | Professional football player; Pro Football Hall of Fame defensive tackle, Dallas Cowboys | [19] |
| Emil Liston | | Former head coach, Baker University, Michigan Technological University | |
| Dallas Long | | Olympic shot putter, 1960 silver medalist, 1964 gold medalist | |
| Ryan Mathews | Fresno State University | Running back, San Diego Chargers, formerly of California State University at Fresno, NCAA Football Leading Rusher of 2009 | |
| John Matuszak | University of Tampa | NFL Hall of Famer; 1st overall pick in the 1973 NFL Draft of the Houston Oilers; played with the Oakland Raiders for the majority of his career; led the Raiders to two Super Bowl Championships (XI & XV) | |
| Keith Moreland | | Professional baseball player; outfielder, Chicago Cubs | |
| James Naismith | | Inventor of the sport of basketball | |
| Davey O'Brien | Texas Christian University | Heisman Trophy-winning quarterback, 1938 | |
| Victor Ortiz | | Professional boxer and former WBC Champion, University of Kansas | |
| Shawn Powell | Florida State University | NFL punter, Buffalo Bills | |
| Jalen Ramsey | Florida State University | NFL cornerback, Los Angeles Rams | |
| Jon Rauch | | Professional baseball player; pitcher, Morehead State University | |
| Dean Refram | | Professional golfer, Florida Southern College | |
| Alma Richards | | Olympic high jumper, 1912 gold medalist | |
| Roy Riegels | | Member of the Rose Bowl Hall of Fame, famed for 1929 Rose Bowl where he was dubbed "Wrong Way" | |
| Johnny Robinson | | Professional football player; strong safety, Kansas City Chiefs, All-Time All-AFL Team | |
| Sandy Sandberg | Iowa Wesleyan University | Professional football player | |
| John Smith | Oklahoma State University | Olympic wrestling champion, freestyle | |
| J. C. Snead | East Tennessee State University | Professional golfer | [19] |
| Jonnie Stewart | University of Memphis | AWA professional wrestler; unsuccessfully ran for U.S. representative in Illinois in 1999 and Illinois governor in 2018 | [20] |
| Bob Todd | | Ohio State University baseball coach | [21] |
| Ron Zook | Miami University | Former head football coach, University of Illinois and University of Florida | |