| Church | Image | Dates | Location | City, State | Description | 
  | Presbyterian Church of Atlanta |   | 1895 built 2010 NRHP-listed
 | 2 Main Street 42°33′13.79″N 77°28′23.33″W / 42.5538306°N 77.4731472°W / 42.5538306; -77.4731472 (Presbyterian Church of Atlanta)
 | Atlanta, New York | Queen Anne, Gothic Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Batavia, New York) |   | 1854 built 2004 NRHP-listed
 | East Main and Liberty Streets 42°59′47″N 78°10′44″W / 42.99639°N 78.17889°W / 42.99639; -78.17889 (First Presbyterian Church (Schenectady, New York))
 | Batavia, New York | Gothic Revival | 
  | Bedford Presbyterian Church (New York) |   | 1872 built 1973 NRHP-listed
 | 44 Village Green 41°12′12″N 73°38′33″W / 41.2032°N 73.6425°W / 41.2032; -73.6425 (Bedford Presbyterian Church)
 | Bedford Village Historic District | Gothic Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Schenectady, New York) |   | 1809 built 2000 NRHP-listed
 | 115 Union Street 42°49′02.6″N 73°56′41.2″W / 42.817389°N 73.944778°W / 42.817389; -73.944778 (First Presbyterian Church (Batavia, New York))
 | Schenectady, New York | New England style, member of the Presbyterian Church in America | 
  | Batchellerville Presbyterian Church |   | 1867 built 2000 NRHP-listed
 | Co. Rt. 7 43°12′33″N 74°3′21″W / 43.20917°N 74.05583°W / 43.20917; -74.05583 (Batchellerville Presbyterian Church)
 | Batchellerville, New York | Greek Revival | 
  | Central Presbyterian Church (New York City) |   | 1821 founded 1922 built
 | 593 Park Avenue 40°45′56.5″N 73°58′01.9″W / 40.765694°N 73.967194°W / 40.765694; -73.967194 (Central Presbyterian Church)
 | New York, New York | Gothic Revival, current building built as Park Avenue Baptist Church by John D. Rockefeller Jr., member of the Evangelical Presbyterian Church (United States) | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Brockport, New York) |   | 1852 built 1999 NRHP-listed
 | 35 State St. 43°12′52″N 77°56′14″W / 43.21444°N 77.93722°W / 43.21444; -77.93722 (First Presbyterian Church (Brockport, New York))
 | Brockport, New York | Greek Revival | 
  | Setauket Presbyterian Church and Burial Ground |   | 1812 built 1996 NRHP-listed
 | 5 Caroline Ave. 40°56′45″N 73°6′41″W / 40.94583°N 73.11139°W / 40.94583; -73.11139 (Setauket Presbyterian Church and Burial Ground)
 | Brookhaven, New York | Federal | 
  | Cuyler Presbyterian Church |   | 1892 built 2001 NRHP-listed
 | 358-360 Pacific St. 40°41′12″N 73°59′11.3″W / 40.68667°N 73.986472°W / 40.68667; -73.986472 (Cuyler Presbyterian Church)
 | Brooklyn, New York | Edward Sargent-designed, Greek Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Buffalo, New York) |   | 1812 founded 1891 built
 |  | Buffalo, New York |  | 
  | Lafayette Avenue Presbyterian Church |   | 1894 built 2009 NRHP-listed
 | 875 Elmwood Avenue 42°55′15.31″N 78°52′37.17″W / 42.9209194°N 78.8769917°W / 42.9209194; -78.8769917 (Lafayette Avenue Presbyterian Church)
 | Buffalo, New York | Romanesque Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Chester |   | 1854 built 1998 NRHP-listed
 | 106-108 Main St. 41°21′25″N 74°16′39″W / 41.35694°N 74.27750°W / 41.35694; -74.27750 (First Presbyterian Church of Chester)
 | Chester, New York | Greek Revival, built for $10,000 | 
  | Cochecton Presbyterian Church |   | 1903 built 1992 NRHP-listed
 | Co. Rd. 114, E of Delaware R. Bridge 41°42′25″N 75°3′52″W / 41.70694°N 75.06444°W / 41.70694; -75.06444 (Cochecton Presbyterian Church)
 | Cochecton, New York | Late 19th and Early 20th Century American Movements, Akron Plan | 
  | Silliman Memorial Presbyterian Church |   | 1897 built 1979 NRHP-listed
 | Mohawk and Seneca Sts. 42°46′28″N 73°42′2″W / 42.77444°N 73.70056°W / 42.77444; -73.70056 (Silliman Memorial Presbyterian Church)
 | Cohoes, New York | Fuller & Wheeler-designed, Romanesque, Richardsonian Romanesque | 
  | Canterbury Presbyterian Church |   | 1826 built 1996 NRHP-listed
 | 41°26′7″N 74°1′53″W / 41.43528°N 74.03139°W / 41.43528; -74.03139 (Canterbury Presbyterian Church) | Cornwall, New York | Federal style | 
  | First Presbyterian Church Complex (Cortland, New York) |   | 1889 built 2002 NRHP-listed
 | 23 Church St. 42°35′57″N 76°10′41″W / 42.59917°N 76.17806°W / 42.59917; -76.17806 (First Presbyterian Church Complex (Cortland, New York))
 | Cortland, New York | Late Victorian, Late 19th and 20th Century Revivals | 
  | Hopewell Presbyterian Church |   | 1831 built 1998 NRHP-listed
 | NY 302, at jct. of NY 17 41°34′14″N 74°20′8″W / 41.57056°N 74.33556°W / 41.57056; -74.33556 (Hopewell Presbyterian Church)
 | Crawford, New York | Gothic Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Delhi, New York) |   | 1882 built 2006 NRHP-listed
 | Clinton St. 42°16′28″N 74°55′21″W / 42.27444°N 74.92250°W / 42.27444; -74.92250 (First Presbyterian Church (Delhi, New York))
 | Delhi, New York | Late Victorian | 
  | South Presbyterian Church |   | 1868-69 built 2000 NRHP-listed
 | 41°0′55″N 73°52′10″W / 41.01528°N 73.86944°W / 41.01528; -73.86944 (South Presbyterian Church) | Dobbs Ferry, New York | Gothic Revival | 
  | Reformed Presbyterian Church Parsonage |  | c.1829 built 1984 NRHP-listed
 | Duanesburg Churches Rd. 42°46′16″N 74°9′26″W / 42.77111°N 74.15722°W / 42.77111; -74.15722 (Reformed Presbyterian Church Parsonage)
 | Duanesburg, New York | Federal, Vernacular Federal | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Dundee, New York) |   | 1895 built 2004 NRHP-listed
 | 31 Main St. 42°31′28″N 76°58′37″W / 42.52444°N 76.97694°W / 42.52444; -76.97694 (First Presbyterian Church (Dundee, New York))
 | Dundee, New York | Romanesque | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Avon |   | 1866 built 2005 NRHP-listed
 | 5605 Avon-Lima Rd. 42°54′35″N 77°42′24″W / 42.90972°N 77.70667°W / 42.90972; -77.70667 (First Presbyterian Church of Avon)
 | East Avon, New York | Federal, Gothic Revival | 
  | East Palmyra Presbyterian Church |  | 1868-69 built 2002 NRHP-listed
 | 2102 Whitbeck Rd. 43°5′2″N 77°8′52″W / 43.08389°N 77.14778°W / 43.08389; -77.14778 (East Palmyra Presbyterian Church)
 | East Palmyra, New York | Romanesque | 
  | St. Paul's German Presbyterian Church and Cemetery |   | 1904 built 2008 NRHP-listed
 | 525 Elmont Rd. 40°41′52″N 73°42′54″W / 40.69778°N 73.71500°W / 40.69778; -73.71500 (St. Paul's German Presbyterian Church and Cemetery)
 | Elmont, New York | Gothic | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Far Rockaway |   | 1908 built 1986 NRHP-listed
 | 1324 Beach Twelfth St. 40°36′34″N 73°44′51″W / 40.60944°N 73.74750°W / 40.60944; -73.74750 (First Presbyterian Church of Far Rockaway)
 | Far Rockaway, New York | Late Gothic Revival style church designed by Ralph Adams Cram, known also as Russell Sage Memorial Church.  Grounds designed by Olmsted Brothers. | 
  | Camroden Presbyterian Church |  | 2007 NRHP-listed | 43°15′12″N 75°16′55″W / 43.25333°N 75.28194°W / 43.25333; -75.28194 (Camroden Presbyterian Church) | Floyd, New York | Greek Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Glens Falls, New York) |   | 1927 built 1984 NRHP-listed
 | 402-410 Glen St. 43°18′44″N 73°38′21″W / 43.31222°N 73.63917°W / 43.31222; -73.63917 (First Presbyterian Church (Glens Falls, New York))
 | Glens Falls, New York | Designed by Cram & Ferguson in Late Gothic Revival | 
  | Greenville Presbyterian Church Complex |   | 1860 built 1985 NRHP-listed
 | North St., NY 32 42°24′58″N 74°01′23″W / 42.41611°N 74.02306°W / 42.41611; -74.02306 (Greenville Presbyterian Church Complex)
 | Greenville, New York |  | 
  | Sparta First Presbyterian Church |   | 1915 built 2007 NRHP-listed
 | 4687 Scottsburg Rd. 42°39′53″N 77°45′59″W / 42.66472°N 77.76639°W / 42.66472; -77.76639 (Sparta First Presbyterian Church)
 | Groveland Station, New York | Late Gothic Revival; it has a crenelated tower. | 
  | Hamilton Union Presbyterian Church |  | 1886 built 1982 NRHP-listed
 | 2291 Western Tpk. 42°42′14″N 73°54′32″W / 42.70389°N 73.90889°W / 42.70389; -73.90889 (Hamilton Union Presbyterian Church)
 | Guilderland, New York | Stick/Eastlake | 
  | Guildford Center Presbyterian Church |  | 1817 built 2004 NRHP-listed
 | Cty Rd. 36 42°24′23″N 75°27′53″W / 42.40639°N 75.46472°W / 42.40639; -75.46472 (Guildford Center Presbyterian Church)
 | Guilford Center, New York | Greek Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Hector |   | 1818 built 2001 NRHP-listed
 | 5519 NY 414 42°30′1″N 76°52′23″W / 42.50028°N 76.87306°W / 42.50028; -76.87306 (First Presbyterian Church of Hector)
 | Hector, New York | Federal | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Highland Falls |   | 1868 built 1982 NRHP-listed
 | 41°22′17″N 73°57′54″W / 41.37139°N 73.96500°W / 41.37139; -73.96500 (First Presbyterian Church of Highland Falls) | Highland Falls, New York | Now is United Methodist Church of the Highlands.  Frederick Clarke Withers-designed in Romanesque Revival | 
  | German Presbyterian Church and Hortonville Cemetery |   | 1860 built 2003 NRHP-listed
 | CR 121 and CR 131 41°46′21″N 75°1′42″W / 41.77250°N 75.02833°W / 41.77250; -75.02833 (German Presbyterian Church and Hortonville Cemetery)
 | Hortonville, New York |  | 
  | Sweet Hollow Presbyterian Church Parsonage |  | 1830 built 1985 NRHP-listed
 | 152 Old Country Rd. 40°47′33″N 73°25′5″W / 40.79250°N 73.41806°W / 40.79250; -73.41806 (Sweet Hollow Presbyterian Church Parsonage)
 | Huntington, New York |  | 
  | First Presbyterian Church in Jamaica |   | 1662 founded |  | Jamaica, Queens, New York | Organized in 1662, it is the oldest continuously serving Presbyterian church in the United States. | 
  | Jewett Presbyterian Church Complex |  | 1848 built 2001 NRHP-listed
 | Church St. 42°16′12″N 74°18′15″W / 42.27000°N 74.30417°W / 42.27000; -74.30417 (Jewett Presbyterian Church Complex)
 | Jewett, New York | Greek Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Le Roy |   | 1826 built 2014 NRHP-listed
 | 7 Clay St. 42°58′38.3″N 77°59′31.6″W / 42.977306°N 77.992111°W / 42.977306; -77.992111 (First Presbyterian Church of Le Roy)
 | Le Roy, New York |  | 
  | Lima Presbyterian Church |   | 1987 CP NRHP-listed | 42°54′19″N 77°36′44″W / 42.90528°N 77.61222°W / 42.90528; -77.61222 (Jewett Presbyterian Church Complex, approximate location) | Lima, New York | Included in the Lima Village Historic District | 
  | United Presbyterian Church (Lisbon, New York) |  | 1857 built 2005 NRHP-listed
 | 26 Church St. 44°43′47″N 75°19′17″W / 44.72972°N 75.32139°W / 44.72972; -75.32139 (United Presbyterian Church (Lisbon, New York))
 | Lisbon, New York | H.J. Horwood-designed | 
  | Lordville Presbyterian Church |   | 1896 built 2000 NRHP-listed
 | Lordville Rd. 41°52′11″N 75°12′57″W / 41.86972°N 75.21583°W / 41.86972; -75.21583 (Lordville Presbyterian Church)
 | Lordville, New York | Late Victorian | 
  | Lowville Presbyterian Church |   | 1831 built 2007 NRHP-listed
 | 7707 North State St. 43°47′28″N 75°29′47″W / 43.79111°N 75.49639°W / 43.79111; -75.49639 (Lowville Presbyterian Church)
 | Lowville, New York | Federal | 
  | Forest Presbyterian Church |  | 1894 built 2004 NRHP-listed
 | 4109 Center St. 43°37′5″N 75°21′41″W / 43.61806°N 75.36139°W / 43.61806; -75.36139 (Forest Presbyterian Church)
 | Lyons Falls, New York | Shingle Style with Gothic elements | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Marcellus |   | 1801 founded 1851 built
 | East Main and North Streets 42°58′58″N 76°20′23″W / 42.9828°N 76.3398°W / 42.9828; -76.3398 (First Presbyterian Church of Marcellus)
 | Marcellus, New York |  | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Margaretville |   | 1894 built 2004 NRHP-listed
 | 42°8′57″N 74°39′6″W / 42.14917°N 74.65167°W / 42.14917; -74.65167 (First Presbyterian Church of Margaretville) | Margaretville, New York | Late Victorian | 
  | Presbyterian Church of McGraw |   | 1901 built 1986 NRHP-listed
 | 3 W. Main St. 42°35′44″N 76°5′45″W / 42.59556°N 76.09583°W / 42.59556; -76.09583 (Presbyterian Church of McGraw)
 | McGraw, New York | Eclectic Queen Anne | 
  | Mendon Presbyterian Church |   | 2005 NRHP-listed | 3886 Rush-Mendon Rd. 43°0′0″N 77°30′25″W / 43.00000°N 77.50694°W / 43.00000; -77.50694 (Mendon Presbyterian Church)
 | Mendon, New York | Gothic | 
  | Middle Island Presbyterian Church |   | 1837 built 2005 NRHP-listed
 | 271 Middle Country Road 40°52′49″N 72°57′48″W / 40.88028°N 72.96333°W / 40.88028; -72.96333 (Middle Island Presbyterian Church)
 | Middle Island, New York | Federal | 
  | Monsey Church |   | 1824 founded | 41°06′44″N 74°04′09″W / 41.112168°N 74.069232°W / 41.112168; -74.069232 (The Monsey Church) | Monsey, New York | Greek Revival with elements of Italianate, joined the Presbyterian Church in America from the Christian Reformed Church in 2005 | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Mumford |   | 1883 built 2002 NRHP-listed
 | George and William Sts. 42°59′32″N 77°51′44″W / 42.99222°N 77.86222°W / 42.99222; -77.86222 (First Presbyterian Church of Mumford)
 | Mumford, New York | Andrew Jackson Warner-designed, Gothic | 
  | New Kingston Presbyterian Church |  | 1900 built 2002 NRHP-listed
 | CR 6 42°12′48″N 74°40′57″W / 42.21333°N 74.68250°W / 42.21333; -74.68250 (New Kingston Presbyterian Church)
 | New Kingston, New York | Late Victorian | 
  | First Presbyterian Church and Lewis Pintard House | .JPG)  | 1710 built 1979 NRHP-listed
 | Pintard Ave. 40°54′16″N 73°47′7″W / 40.90444°N 73.78528°W / 40.90444; -73.78528 (First Presbyterian Church and Lewis Pintard House)
 | New Rochelle, New York | John Russell Pope-designed, Colonial Revival | 
  | Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church |   | 1808 founded 1875 built
 | Fifth Avenue at 55th Street 40°45′43″N 73°58′30″W / 40.76194°N 73.97500°W / 40.76194; -73.97500 (Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church)
 | New York City | Gothic Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Manhattan |   | 1716 founded 1844–46 built
 | 48 Fifth Avenue 40°44′4″N 73°59′42″W / 40.73444°N 73.99500°W / 40.73444; -73.99500 (First Presbyterian Church of Manhattan)
 | New York City | Gothic Revival | 
  | Fort Washington Presbyterian Church |   | 1913 built 2010 NRHP-listed
 | 21 Wadsworth Ave. 40°50′43.35″N 73°56′16.24″W / 40.8453750°N 73.9378444°W / 40.8453750; -73.9378444 (Fort Washington Presbyterian Church)
 | New York, New York | Georgian Revival | 
  | New York Presbyterian Church |   | 1884 built 1982 NRHP-listed
 | 151 W. 128th St. 40°48′39″N 73°56′49″W / 40.81083°N 73.94694°W / 40.81083; -73.94694 (New York Presbyterian Church)
 | New York, New York | Served until 1918 as a Presbyterian church, then acquired by a Baptist church.  Gothic, Romanesque | 
  | Redeemer Presbyterian Church |   | 1989 founded | Multiple locations 40°45′07″N 73°59′17″W / 40.75190°N 73.98798°W / 40.75190; -73.98798 (Redeemer Presbyterian Church) | New York, New York |  | 
  | Riverdale Presbyterian Church Complex |   | 1863 built 1982 NRHP-listed
 | 4761-4765 Henry Hudson Parkway 40°53′45″N 73°54′32″W / 40.89583°N 73.90889°W / 40.89583; -73.90889 (Riverdale Presbyterian Church Complex)
 | New York, New York | James Renwick Jr. and Dwight J. Baum-designed; Late Gothic Revival, Stick/Eastlake | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Ontario Center |   | 1914 built 1998 NRHP-listed
 | 1638 Ridge Rd. 43°13′31″N 77°18′6″W / 43.22528°N 77.30167°W / 43.22528; -77.30167 (First Presbyterian Church of Ontario Center)
 | Ontario Center, New York | Tudor Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Oyster Bay |   | 1873 built 1976 NRHP-listed
 | 40°52′18.25″N 73°31′45.35″W / 40.8717361°N 73.5292639°W / 40.8717361; -73.5292639 (First Presbyterian Church of Oyster Bay) | Oyster Bay, New York | J. Cleveland Cady-designed in Stick/Eastlake style | 
  | Peekskill Presbyterian Church |   | 1846 built 2002 NRHP-listed
 | 41°17′19″N 73°55′27″W / 41.28861°N 73.92417°W / 41.28861; -73.92417 (Peekskill Presbyterian Church) | Peekskill, New York | Greek Revival | 
  | Brick Presbyterian Church |   | 1909 built 2007 NRHP-listed
 | 6 Church Street 42°43′14.9982″N 78°0′4.7412″W / 42.720832833°N 78.001317000°W / 42.720832833; -78.001317000 (Brick Presbyterian Church)
 | Perry, New York | Gothic Revival | 
  | Smithfield Presbyterian Church |   | 1820 built 1994 NRHP-listed
 | Pleasant Valley Rd. between Elizabeth and Park Sts. 42°57′56″N 75°41′17″W / 42.96556°N 75.68806°W / 42.96556; -75.68806 (Smithfield Presbyterian Church)
 | Peterboro, New York | Italianate, Federal | 
  | Childwold Memorial Presbyterian Church |   | 1903 built 2001 NRHP-listed
 | Bancroft Rd. 44°17′5″N 74°40′9″W / 44.28472°N 74.66917°W / 44.28472; -74.66917 (Childwold Memorial Presbyterian Church)
 | Piercefield, New York | Queen Anne | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Plattsburgh, New York) |   | 1868 built 1982 NRHP-listed
 | 34 Brinkerhoff St. 44°41′50″N 73°27′16″W / 44.69722°N 73.45444°W / 44.69722; -73.45444 (First Presbyterian Church (Plattsburgh, New York))
 | Plattsburgh, New York | Gothic | 
  | Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church |   | 1888 built 1995 NRHP-listed
 | Jct. of Church and S. Main Sts., NW corner, Town of Moriah 44°2′53″N 73°27′39″W / 44.04806°N 73.46083°W / 44.04806; -73.46083 (Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church)
 | Port Henry, New York | Romanesque | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Dailey Ridge |  | 1853 built 2002 NRHP-listed
 | 411 Elliot Rd. 44°44′48″N 75°3′48″W / 44.74667°N 75.06333°W / 44.74667; -75.06333 (First Presbyterian Church of Dailey Ridge)
 | Potsdam, New York | Greek Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Poughkeepsie, New York) |   | 1905 built 1982 NRHP-listed
 | 25 S. Hamilton St. 41°42′4″N 73°55′29″W / 41.70111°N 73.92472°W / 41.70111; -73.92472 (First Presbyterian Church (Poughkeepsie, New York))
 | Poughkeepsie, New York | Romanesque | 
  | First Presbyterian Church Rectory (Poughkeepsie, New York) |   | c.1857 built 1982 NRHP-listed
 | 98 Cannon St. 41°42′4″N 73°55′31″W / 41.70111°N 73.92528°W / 41.70111; -73.92528 (First Presbyterian Church Rectory (Poughkeepsie, New York))
 | Poughkeepsie, New York | Second Empire | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Preble, New York) |   | 1831 built 2002 NRHP-listed
 | Courtland Cty Rd. 108B 42°44′6″N 76°8′47″W / 42.73500°N 76.14639°W / 42.73500; -76.14639 (First Presbyterian Church (Preble, New York))
 | Preble, New York | Federal, Colonial Revival | 
  | Brick Presbyterian Church Complex |   | 1860 built 1992 NRHP-listed
 | 121 N. Fitzhugh St. 43°9′27″N 77°37′1″W / 43.15750°N 77.61694°W / 43.15750; -77.61694 (Brick Presbyterian Church Complex)
 | Rochester, New York | Colonial Revival, Early Romanesque Revival | 
  | Emmanuel Presbyterian Church |   | 1915 built 2001 NRHP-listed
 | Jefferson Ave. at 9 Shelter St. 43°8′19″N 77°37′47″W / 43.13861°N 77.62972°W / 43.13861; -77.62972 (Emmanuel Presbyterian Church)
 | Rochester, New York | Late 19th and Early 20th Century American Movements | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Rochester, New York) |   | 1871 built 1973 NRHP-listed
 | 101 S. Plymouth Ave. 43°9′10″N 77°36′56″W / 43.15278°N 77.61556°W / 43.15278; -77.61556 (First Presbyterian Church (Rochester, New York))
 | Rochester, New York | Gothic, designed by Andrew J. Warner | 
  | Roscoe Presbyterian Church and Westfield Flats Cemetery |   | c.1884 built 2001 NRHP-listed
 | Old NY 17 41°55′56″N 74°54′47″W / 41.93222°N 74.91306°W / 41.93222; -74.91306 (Roscoe Presbyterian Church and Westfield Flats Cemetery)
 | Roscoe, New York | Late Victorian | 
  | Old Whaler's Church (First Presbyterian Church of Sag Harbor) |   | 1766 founded 1844 built
 1994 NHL-designated
 | 44 Union Street 40°59′50″N 72°17′38.66″W / 40.99722°N 72.2940722°W / 40.99722; -72.2940722 (Old Whaler's Church)
 | Sag Harbor, New York | Minard Lafever-designed in Egyptian Revival style, with Greek Revival elements | 
  | Union Presbyterian Church (Scottsville, New York) |   | 2004 NRHP-listed | Church St. 43°1′18″N 77°45′7″W / 43.02167°N 77.75194°W / 43.02167; -77.75194 (Union Presbyterian Church (Scottsville, New York))
 | Scottsville, New York | Exotic Revival; also known as First Presbyterian Church of Wheatland | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Smithtown, New York) |   | 1825 built 1977 NRHP-listed
 | 175 E. Main St. 40°51′24″N 73°11′18″W / 40.85667°N 73.18833°W / 40.85667; -73.18833 (First Presbyterian Church (Smithtown, New York))
 | Smithtown, New York |  | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Spencer, New York) |   | 1915 built 2005 NRHP-listed
 | 75-77 N. Main St. 42°12′50″N 76°29′33″W / 42.21389°N 76.49250°W / 42.21389; -76.49250 (First Presbyterian Church (Spencer, New York))
 | Spencer, New York | Gothic Revival | 
  | St. Peter's Presbyterian Church and Spencertown Cemetery |   | 1771 built 2002 NRHP-listed
 | 42°19′23″N 73°32′46″W / 42.32306°N 73.54611°W / 42.32306; -73.54611 (St. Peter's Presbyterian Church and Spencertown Cemetery) | Spencertown, New York | Federal | 
  | Seneca Presbyterian Church |  | 1838 built 1973 NRHP-listed
 | 42°48′20″N 77°3′5″W / 42.80556°N 77.05139°W / 42.80556; -77.05139 (Seneca Presbyterian Church) | Stanley, New York |  | 
  | Calvary Presbyterian Church (Staten Island, New York) |   | 1894 built 2002 NRHP-listed
 | 909 Castleton Ave. 40°38′6″N 74°6′46″W / 40.63500°N 74.11278°W / 40.63500; -74.11278 (Calvary Presbyterian Church (Staten Island, New York))
 | Staten Island, New York | Romanesque, Tudor Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Ulysses | .jpg)  | built NRHP-listed
 | Main St. 42°32′29″N 76°39′34″W / 42.54139°N 76.65944°W / 42.54139; -76.65944 (First Presbyterian Church of Ulysses)
 | Trumansburg, New York | Greek Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Tuscarora |   | 2004 NRHP-listed | 8082 Main St. 42°38′3″N 77°52′12″W / 42.63417°N 77.87000°W / 42.63417; -77.87000 (First Presbyterian Church of Tuscarora)
 | Tuscarora, New York | Greek Revival | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Utica, New York) |   | 1920 built 1988 NRHP-listed
 | 43°5′29″N 75°15′1″W / 43.09139°N 75.25028°W / 43.09139; -75.25028 (First Presbyterian Church (Utica, New York)) | Utica, New York | Ralph Adams Cram-designed | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Valatie, New York) |   | 1878 built 1979 NRHP-listed
 | Church St. 42°24′55″N 73°40′36″W / 42.41528°N 73.67667°W / 42.41528; -73.67667 (First Presbyterian Church (Valatie, New York))
 | Valatie, New York | Gothic | 
  | Wanakena Presbyterian Church |   | 1903 built 2007 NRHP-listed
 | 32 Second St. 44°8′9″N 74°55′18″W / 44.13583°N 74.92167°W / 44.13583; -74.92167 (Wanakena Presbyterian Church)
 | Wanakena, New York | Late Victorian | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Waterloo, New York) |   | 1850 built 1996 NRHP-listed
 | E. Main St., E of jct. with NY 96 42°54′14″N 76°51′39″W / 42.90389°N 76.86083°W / 42.90389; -76.86083 (First Presbyterian Church (Waterloo, New York))
 | Waterloo, New York | Romanesque | 
  | West Charlton United Presbyterian Church |   | c.1880 built 1998 NRHP-listed
 | 1331 Sacandaga Rd. 42°58′22″N 74°1′50″W / 42.97278°N 74.03056°W / 42.97278; -74.03056 (West Charlton United Presbyterian Church)
 | West Charlton, New York | Late Victorian | 
  | West Delhi Presbyterian Church, Manse, and Cemetery |   | 1892 built 2008 NRHP-listed
 | 18 and 45 Sutherland Rd. 42°18′0.41″N 75°0′25.29″W / 42.3001139°N 75.0070250°W / 42.3001139; -75.0070250 (West Delhi Presbyterian Church, Manse, and Cemetery)
 | West Delhi, New York | Late Victorian | 
  | West Kortright Presbyterian Church |   | 1850 built 2002 NRHP-listed
 | 49 W. Kortright Church Rd. 42°24′8″N 74°51′8″W / 42.40222°N 74.85222°W / 42.40222; -74.85222 (West Kortright Presbyterian Church)
 | West Kortright, New York | Late Victorian | 
  | First Congregational and Presbyterian Society Church of Westport |  | 1837 built 1988 NRHP-listed
 | Main St./CR 10 44°13′50″N 73°27′33″W / 44.23056°N 73.45917°W / 44.23056; -73.45917 (First Congregational and Presbyterian Society Church of Westport)
 | Westport, New York | Federal | 
  | Centre Presbyterian Church |   | 1835 built 1979 NRHP-listed
 | Main and Church Sts 42°18′24″N 74°15′9″W / 42.30667°N 74.25250°W / 42.30667; -74.25250 (Centre Presbyterian Church)
 | Windham, New York | Greek Revival, Federal | 
  | First Presbyterian Church (Wolcott, New York) |   | 1883 built 
 | W. Main St. 43°13′12″N 76°48′58″W / 43.22000°N 76.81611°W / 43.22000; -76.81611 (First Presbyterian Church (Wolcott, New York))
 | Wolcott, New York | Romanesque Revival; polychrome masonry;  one of three contributing buildings in Wolcott Square Historic District | 
  | First Presbyterian Church of Yorktown |   | 1840 built | 2880 Crompond Road 41°17′39″N 73°48′33″W / 41.2943°N 73.8091°W / 41.2943; -73.8091 (First Presbyterian Church of Yorktown)
 | Yorktown, New York | Listed on the APRHS #4, founded 1730, burned by the British 1779, rebuilt 1785[7] | 
  | Caldwell Presbyterian Church |   | mid-1850s built | 71 Montcalm St. 43°25′30″N 73°42′54″W / 43.425083°N 73.714925°W / 43.425083; -73.714925 (Caldwell Presbyterian Church)
 | Lake George, New York | NRHP listed Listed 4/12/2016, number 16000164 | 
   | Redeemer Presbyterian Church (New York, New York) |  | 1989 
 | 150 West 83rd Street 
 | New York, New York | A PCA church, one of the most influential Presbyterian churches in America founded by Tim Keller |