| Rank | Name | Years | Wins | Losses | Ties | Pct. | Teams |
| 1 | Mike Martin† | 40 | 2,029 | 736 | 4 | .733 | Florida State (1980–2019) |
| 2 | Augie Garrido† | 48 | 1,975 | 951 | 9 | .674 | San Francisco State (1969), Cal Poly (1970–1972), Cal State Fullerton (1973–1987, 1991–1996), Illinois (1988–1990), Texas (1997–2016) |
| 3 | Gordie Gillespie† | 59 | 1,893 | 952 | 1 | .665 | Lewis (1953–1976), St. Francis (Ill.) (1977–1995, 2006-2011), Ripon (1996–2005) |
| 4 | Gene Stephenson† | 36 | 1,768 | 675 | 3 | .723 | Wichita State (1978–2013) |
| 5 | Ed Cheff† | 34 | 1,705 | 430 | 2 | .799 | Lewis-Clark State (1977–2010)[4] |
| 6 | Woody Hunt | 40 | 1,630 | 774 | 5 | .678 | Cumberland (TN) (1980–2021)[5] |
| 7 | Mark Marquess† | 40 | 1,627 | 878 | 7 | .649 | Stanford (1977–2017) |
| 8 | Denney Crabaugh | 34 | 1,601 | 493 | 2 | .764 | Oklahoma City (1989–2022) |
| 9 | Jim Morris† | 37 | 1,594 | 716 | 4 | .690 | Georgia Tech (1982–1993), Miami (FL) (1994–2018) |
| 10 | Paul Mainieri* | 40 | 1,533 | 806 | 7 | .655 | St. Thomas (FL) (1983–1988), Air Force (1989–1994), Notre Dame (1995–2006), LSU (2007–2021), South Carolina (2025–present) |
| 11 | Larry Hays† | 38 | 1,508 | 860 | 4 | .637 | Lubbock Christian (1971–1986), Texas Tech (1987–2008) |
| 12 | Mike Fox | 37 | 1,487 | 547 | 5 | .731 | NC Wesleyan (1983–1994, 1996–1998), North Carolina (1999–2020) |
| 13 | Danny Hall | 38 | 1,452 | 793 | 1 | .647 | Kent State (1988–1993), Georgia Tech (1994–2025) |
| 14 | Chuck Hartman | 47 | 1,444 | 816 | 8 | .638 | High Point (1960–1978), Virginia Tech (1979–2006) |
| 15 | Don Schaly† | 40 | 1,438 | 329 | 13 | .812 | Marietta (1964–2003) |
| 16 | Cliff Gustafson† | 29 | 1,427 | 373 | 2 | .792 | Texas (1968–1996) |
| 17 | Bill Holowaty† | 44 | 1,412 | 528 | 7 | .727 | Eastern Connecticut State (1969–2012) |
| 18 | Keith Guttin | 42 | 1,396 | 929 | 0 | .600 | Missouri State (1983–2024) |
| 19 | John Anderson | 43 | 1,390 | 1,021 | 3 | .576 | Minnesota (1982–2024) |
| 20 | Bobby Cox | 35 | 1,378 | 643 | 0 | .682 | Oklahoma Baptist (1985–2019) |
| 21 | Bobby Halford* | 40 | 1,375 | 814 | 0 | .628 | William Carey (1986–present) |
| 22 | Ron Polk† | 35 | 1,373 | 702 | 2 | .662 | Georgia Southern (1972–1975), Mississippi State (1976–1997, 2002–2008), Georgia (2000–2001) |
| 23 | Gary Gilmore | 35 | 1,371 | 699 | 5 | .662 | South Carolina Aiken (1990–1995), Coastal Carolina (1996–2024) |
| 24 | Jim Gilligan | 40 | 1,353 | 895 | 7 | .602 | Western New Mexico (1972), Lamar (1973–1986, 1992–2016) |
| 25 | John Schaly* | 38 | 1,351 | 740 | 4 | .646 | Barry (1988–1991), Saint Leo (FL) (1992–1997), Ashland (1998–present) |
| 26 | Lou Yacinich | 45 | 1,347 | 1,058 | 0 | .560 | Grand View (1974–2022) |
| 27 | Bob Babb* | 46 | 1,346 | 483 | 16 | .734 | Johns Hopkins (1980–present) |
| 28 | Rod Dedeaux† | 44 | 1,342 | 597 | 16 | .691 | USC (1942–1947, 1949–1986) |
| 29 | Jack Leggett | 36 | 1,332 | 770 | 1 | .634 | Vermont (1978–1982), Western Carolina (1983–1991), Clemson (1994–2015) |
| 30 | Larry Cochell | 39 | 1,331 | 813 | 3 | .621 | Emporia State (1967–1969), Creighton (1970–1971), Cal State Los Angeles (1972–1976), Oral Roberts (1977–1986), Northwestern (1987), Cal State Fullerton (1988–1990), Oklahoma (1991–2005) |
| 31 | Mike Metheny† | 37 | 1,324 | 679 | 3 | .668 | Southeastern Oklahoma State (1981–2017) |
| 32 | Tom Austin* | 46 | 1,318 | 632 | 10 | .675 | Methodist University (1980–present) |
| 33 | Joe Roberts | 34 | 1,314 | 640 | 6 | .672 | Armstrong Atlantic (1980–2013) |
| 34 | Pete Dunn | 37 | 1,312 | 887 | 3 | .597 | Stetson (1980–2016) |
| 35 | Tommy Thomas† | 40 | 1,308 | 825 | 6 | .613 | Valdosta State (1968–2007) |
| 36 | Dave Van Horn* | 32 | 1,304 | 640 | 0 | .671 | Central Missouri State (1994), Northwestern State (1995–1997), Nebraska (1998–2002), Arkansas (2003–present) |
| 37 | Bob Bennett† | 34 | 1,300 | 757 | 8 | .631 | Fresno State (1967, 1970–2002) |
| 38 | Elliott Avent* | 37 | 1,295 | 847 | 2 | .604 | New Mexico State (1989–1996), NC State (1997–present) |
| 39 | Ron Fraser† | 30 | 1,267 | 440 | 9 | .741 | Miami (FL) (1963–1992) |
| 40 | Jack Stallings | 39 | 1,255 | 799 | 10 | .610 | Wake Forest (1960–1968), Florida State (1969–1974), Georgia Southern 1976–1999 |
| 41 | Charlie Migl | 35 | 1,246 | 600 | 0 | .675 | St. Mary's (TX) (1987–2021) |
| 42 | Tim Pettorini | 38 | 1,243 | 460 | 6 | .729 | Wooster (1982–2019) |
| 43 | Q. V. Lowe | 28 | 1,242 | 689 | 5 | .643 | Auburn Montgomery (1987–2014) |
| 43 | Itch Jones | 39 | 1,242 | 752 | 6 | .623 | MacMurray (1966–1968), Southern Illinois (1970–1990), Illinois (1991–2005) |
| 45 | Jim Dietz | 31 | 1,230 | 751 | 18 | .620 | San Diego State (1972–2002) |
| 46 | Jay Bergman | 32 | 1,210 | 707 | 3 | .631 | Florida (1976–1981), UCF (1983–2008) |
| 47 | Greg Guilliams* | 35 | 1,208 | 600 | 2 | .668 | Penn State–Behrend (1991), Embry–Riddle (FL) (1992–2007), Valdosta State (2008–2024), Flagler (2025–Present) |
| 47 | Al Ogletree | 40 | 1,208 | 710 | 1 | .630 | Dallas (1958–1965), Sul Ross State (1966–1968), Texas–Pan American (1969–1997) |
| 47 | Rich Hill* | 38 | 1,208 | 819 | 4 | .596 | Cal Lutheran (1988–1993), San Francisco (1994–1998), San Diego (1999–2021), Hawaii (2022–present) |
| 50 | George Valesente | 47 | 1,204 | 544 | 8 | .688 | Brockport (1973–1974), SUNY New Paltz (1975–1976), SUNY Maritime (1977–1978), Ithaca (1979–2019) |
| 51 | Jim Mallon | 34 | 1,196 | 602 | 1 | .665 | Southwestern (1971–2004) |
| 52 | Scott Berry | 42 | 1,196 | 698 | 1 | .631 | Mayville State (1982–2023) |
| 53 | Jeff Sikes | 39 | 1,189 | 886 | 5 | .573 | Warner (FL) (1982–2023) |
| 54 | Andy Lopez† | 33 | 1,177 | 742 | 7 | .613 | Cal State Dominguez Hills (1983–1988), Pepperdine (1989–1994), Florida (1995–2001), Arizona (2002–2015) |
| 55 | John Goelz | 38 | 1,175 | 836 | 5 | .587 | Sonoma State (1986–2024) |
| 56 | Wayne Graham† | 26 | 1,173 | 528 | 2 | .689 | Rice (1992–2018) |
| 56 | Tony Robichaux | 36 | 1,173 | 765 | 2 | .605 | McNeese State (1987–1994), Louisiana (1995–2019) |
| 58 | Gary Adams | 35 | 1,172 | 892 | 12 | .567 | UC Irvine (1970–1974), UCLA (1975–2004) |
| 59 | Keith Veale* | 36 | 1,163 | 616 | 0 | .654 | Mount Vernon Nazarene (1990–present) |
| 60 | Bill Wilhelm† | 36 | 1,161 | 536 | 10 | .683 | Clemson (1958–1993) |
| 60 | Norm DeBriyn | 33 | 1,161 | 650 | 6 | .641 | Arkansas (1970–2002) |
| 60 | Mike Laird* | 43 | 1,161 | 698 | 3 | .624 | William Penn (1983–present) |
| 63 | Jack Coffey† | 47 | 1,160 | 482 | 13 | .705 | Fordham (1909–1917, 1919–1921, 1923–1943, 1945–1958)[6] |
| 64 | Chuck Brayton† | 33 | 1,158 | 525 | 6 | .687 | Washington State (1962–1994) |
| 64 | Mike Sansing | 33 | 1,158 | 693 | 0 | .626 | Shorter (1989–1991), Kennesaw State (1992–2021) |
| 66 | Mike Gillespie | 30 | 1,156 | 720 | 2 | .616 | USC (1987–2006), UC Irvine (2008–2018) |
| 67 | Jeff Messer* | 40 | 1,154 | 760 | 5 | .603 | Slippery Rock (1986–Present) |
| 68 | Ken Dugan† | 37 | 1,137 | 450 | 0 | .716 | Lipscomb (1960–1996) |
| 69 | Ray Tanner | 25 | 1,133 | 489 | 3 | .698 | NC State (1988–1996), South Carolina (1997–2012) |
| 69 | Ed Flaherty | 39 | 1,133 | 532 | 4 | .680 | Southern Maine (1986–2024) |
| 71 | Frank Vieira† | 44 | 1,127 | 324 | 6 | .776 | New Haven (1963–2006) |
| 72 | Bob Fornelli* | 29 | 1,120 | 495 | 0 | .693 | Fort Hayes State (1997–2003), Emporia State (2004–2018), Pittsburg State (2019–present) |
| 73 | Chris Hanks* | 27 | 1,111 | 428 | 0 | .722 | Colorado Mesa (1999–present) |
| 74 | Don Brandon | 38 | 1,110 | 588 | 5 | .653 | Anderson (IN) (1972, 1974–2010) |
| 75 | Jim Harp | 27 | 1,107 | 553 | 2 | .660 | Dallas Baptist (1973–1999) |