| Season | Tournament champion | Score | Tournament runner-up | Venue |
| 1982 | Tennessee Tech | 80–66 | Morehead State | Cookeville, TN (Eblen Center) |
| 1983 | Middle Tennessee State | 74–61 | Morehead State | Cookeville, TN (Eblen Center) |
| 1984 | Middle Tennessee State (2) | 71–61 | Tennessee Tech | Murfreesboro, TN (Murphy Center) |
| 1985 | Middle Tennessee State (3) | 67–61 | Tennessee Tech | Murfreesboro, TN (Murphy Center) |
| 1986 | Middle Tennessee State (4) | 66–63 | Tennessee Tech | Murfreesboro, TN (Murphy Center) |
| 1987 | Tennessee Tech (2) | 71–67 | Middle Tennessee State | Murfreesboro, TN (Murphy Center) |
| 1988 | Middle Tennessee State (5) | 79–62 | Tennessee Tech | Murfreesboro, TN (Murphy Center) |
| 1989 | Tennessee Tech (3) | 80–79 | Murray State | Murfreesboro, TN (Murphy Center) |
| 1990 | Tennessee Tech (4) | 79–72 | Murray State | Cookeville, TN (Eblen Center) |
| 1991 | Tennessee Tech (5) | 84–59 | Middle Tennessee State | Cookeville, TN (Eblen Center) |
| 1992 | Tennessee Tech (6) | 81–74 | Eastern Kentucky | Cookeville, TN (Eblen Center) |
| 1993 | Tennessee Tech (7) | 80–73 | Middle Tennessee State | Cookeville, TN (Eblen Center) |
| 1994 | Tennessee State | 71–63 | Tennessee Tech | Cookeville, TN (Eblen Center) |
| 1995 | Tennessee State (2) | 66–63 | Tennessee Tech | Nashville, TN (Nashville Municipal Auditorium) |
| 1996 | Austin Peay | 69–60 | Middle Tennessee State | Nashville, TN (Nashville Municipal Auditorium) |
| 1997 | Eastern Kentucky | 69–65 | Tennessee Tech | Nashville, TN (Nashville Municipal Auditorium) |
| 1998 | Middle Tennessee State (6) | 59–58 | UT Martin | Nashville, TN (Nashville Arena) |
| 1999 | Tennessee Tech (8) | 86–83 | UT Martin | Nashville, TN (Nashville Arena) |
| 2000 | Tennessee Tech (9) | 89–80 | Austin Peay | Nashville, TN (Gaylord Entertainment Center) |
| 2001 | Austin Peay (2) | 65–63 | Tennessee Tech | Nashville, TN (Gaylord Entertainment Center) |
| 2002 | Austin Peay (3) | 85–83 | Tennessee Tech | Louisville, KY (Kentucky International Convention Center) |
| 2003 | Austin Peay (4) | 85–61 | Southeast Missouri State | Nashville, TN (Gaylord Entertainment Center) |
| 2004 | Austin Peay (5) | 65–51 | Eastern Kentucky | Nashville, TN (Nashville Municipal Auditorium) |
| 2005 | Eastern Kentucky (2) | 84–73 (2OT) | Southeast Missouri State | Nashville, TN (Gaylord Entertainment Center) |
| 2006 | Southeast Missouri State † | 71–50 | Tennessee Tech | Nashville, TN (Gaylord Entertainment Center) |
| 2007 | Southeast Missouri State | 62–60 | Murray State | Nashville, TN (Gaylord Entertainment Center) |
| 2008 | Murray State | 69–58 | Eastern Illinois | Nashville, TN (Nashville Municipal Auditorium) |
| 2009 | Austin Peay (6) | 69–65 (2OT) | Eastern Illinois | Nashville, TN (Sommet Center) |
| 2010 | Austin Peay (7) | 69–60 | Eastern Illinois | Nashville, TN (Bridgestone Arena) |
| 2011 | UT Martin | 82–76 | Tennessee Tech | Nashville, TN (Nashville Municipal Auditorium) |
| 2012 | UT Martin (2) | 82–65 | Tennessee Tech | Nashville, TN (Nashville Municipal Auditorium) |
| 2013 | UT Martin (3) | 87–80 (OT) | Tennessee Tech | Nashville, TN (Nashville Municipal Auditorium) |
| 2014 | UT Martin (4) | 78–66 | Belmont | Nashville, TN (Nashville Municipal Auditorium) |
| 2015 | Tennessee State (3) | 64–60 | UT Martin | Nashville, TN (Nashville Municipal Auditorium) |
| 2016 | Belmont | 95–63 | Eastern Kentucky | Nashville, TN (Nashville Municipal Auditorium) |
| 2017 | Belmont (2) | 94–64 | Eastern Kentucky | Nashville, TN (Nashville Municipal Auditorium) |
| 2018 | Belmont (3) | 63–56 | UT Martin | Evansville, IN (Ford Center) |
| 2019 | Belmont (4) | 59–53 | UT Martin | Evansville, IN (Ford Center) |
| 2020 | Southeast Missouri State (2) | 67–47 | UT Martin | Evansville, IN (Ford Center) |
| 2021 | Belmont (5) | 83–75 | UT Martin | Evansville, IN (Ford Center) |
| 2022 | Belmont (6) | 51–29 | Tennessee Tech | Evansville, IN (Ford Center) |
| 2023 | Tennessee Tech (10) | 54–46 | Little Rock | Evansville, IN (Ford Center) |
| 2024 | Southern Indiana | 83–51 | UT Martin | Evansville, IN (Ford Center) |
| 2025 | Tennessee Tech (11) | 82-76 (OT) | Lindenwood | Evansville, IN (Ford Center) |