| Year  |  Film  |  Writer(s)  | 
  1970 (23rd)[24]  |  Best Comedy Adapted from Another Medium  | 
  | M*A*S*H †  |  Ring Lardner Jr.  | 
  | Lovers and Other Strangers  |  Renée Taylor, Joseph Bologna, David Zelag Goodman  | 
  | The Owl and the Pussycat  |  Buck Henry  | 
  | The Twelve Chairs  |  Mel Brooks  | 
  | Where's Poppa  |  Robert Klane  | 
  | Best Comedy Written Directly for the Screen  | 
  | The Out-of-Towners  |  Neil Simon  | 
  | The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes  |  Billy Wilder, and I.A.L. Diamond  | 
  | Quackser Fortune Has a Cousin in the Bronk  |  Gabriel Walsh  | 
  | Start the Revolution Without Me  |  Fred Freeman, and Lawrence J. Cohen  | 
  | The Cheyenne Social Club  |  James Lee Barrett  | 
  1971 (24th)[25]  |  Best Comedy Adapted from Another Medium  | 
  | Kotch  |  John Paxton  | 
  | A New Leaf  |  Elaine May  | 
  | Fiddler on the Roof  |  Joseph Stein  | 
  | Little Murders  |  Jules Feiffer  | 
  | The Boy Friend  |  Ken Russell  | 
  | Best Comedy Written Directly for the Screen  | 
  | The Hospital  |  Paddy Chayefsky  | 
  | Bananas  |  Woody Allen, and Mickey Rose  | 
  | Carnal Knowledge  |  Jules Feiffer  | 
  | Made for Each Other  |  Renée Taylor, and Joseph Bologna  | 
  | Taking Off  |  Miloṡ Forman, Jean-Claude Carrière, John Guare, and Jon Klein  | 
  1972 (25th)[26]  |  Best Comedy Adapted from Another Medium  | 
  | Cabaret ‡  |  Jay Presson Allen  | 
  | Avanti!  |  Billy Wilder, and I.A.L. Diamond  | 
  | Butterflies Are Free  |  Leonard Gershe  | 
  | The Heartbreak Kid  |  Neil Simon  | 
  | Travels with My Aunt  |  Jay Presson Allen, and Hugh Wheeler  | 
  | Best Comedy Written Directly for the Screen  | 
  | What's Up, Doc?  |  Peter Bogdanovich, Buck Henry, David Newman, and Robert Benton  | 
  | Get to Know Your Rabbit  |  Jordan Crittenden  | 
  | Hammersmith Is Out  |  Stanford Whitmore  | 
  | Minnie and Moskowitz  |  John Cassavetes  | 
  | The War Between Men and Women  |  Melville Shavelson, and Danny Arnold  | 
  1973 (26th)[27]  |  Best Comedy Adapted from Another Medium  | 
  | Paper Moon ‡  |  Alvin Sargent  | 
  | 40 Carats  |  Leonard Gershe  | 
  | Godspell  |  David Greenne, and John-Michael Tebelak  | 
  | Best Comedy Written Directly for the Screen  | 
  | A Touch of Class‡  |  Melvin Frank and Jack Rose  | 
  | American Graffiti ‡  |  George Lucas, Gloria Katz, and Willard Huyck  | 
  | Blume in Love  |  Paul Mazursky  | 
  | Sleeper  |  Woody Allen, and Marshall Brickman  | 
  | Slither  |  W.D. Richter  | 
  1974 (27th)[28]  |  Best Comedy Adapted from Another Medium  | 
  | The Apprenticeship of Duddy Kravitz ‡  |  Mordecai Richler, and Lionel Chetwynd  | 
  | The Front Page  |  Billy Wilder, and I.A.L. Diamond  | 
  | Young Frankenstein ‡  |  Gene Wilder, and Mel Brooks  | 
  | Best Comedy Written Directly for the Screen  | 
  | Blazing Saddles  |   Mel Brooks, Norman Steinberg, Andrew Bergman, Richard Pryor, and Alan Uger  | 
  | California Split  |  Joseph Walsh  | 
  | Claudine  |  Tina Pine, and Lester Pine  | 
  | Phantom of the Paradise  |  Brian de Palma  | 
  | The Sugarland Express  |  Hal Barwood, Matthew Robbins, and Steven Spielberg  | 
  1975 (28th)[29]  |  Best Comedy Adapted from Another Medium  | 
  | The Sunshine Boys ‡  |  Neil Simon  | 
  | Hester Street  |  Joan Micklin Silver  | 
  | The Prisoner of Second Avenue  |  Neil Simon  | 
  | Best Comedy Written Directly for the Screen  | 
  | Shampoo ‡  |   Robert Towne and Warren Beatty  | 
  | Heats of the West  |  Rob Thompson  | 
  | Smile  |  Jerry Belson  | 
  | The Return of the Pink Panther  |  Frank Waldman, and Blake Edwards  | 
  1976 (29th)[30]  |  Best Comedy Adapted from Another Medium  | 
  | The Pink Panther Strikes Again  |  Frank Waldman, and Blake Edwards  | 
  | Family Plot  |  Ernest Lehman  | 
  | Stay Hungry  |  Charles Gaines, and Bob Rafelson  | 
  | The Bingo Long Traveling All-Stars & Motor Kings  |  Hal Barwood, and Matthew Robbins  | 
  | The Ritz  |  Terrence McNally  | 
  | Best Comedy Written Directly for the Screen  | 
  | The Bad News Bears  |  Bill Lancaster  | 
  | Murder by Death  |  Neil Simon  | 
  | Next Stop, Greenwich Village  |  Paul Mazursky  | 
  | Silent Movie  |  Mel Brooks, Ron Clark, Rudy De Luca, and Barry Levinson  | 
  | Silver Streak  |  Colin Higgins  | 
  1977 (30th)[31]  |  Best Comedy Adapted from Another Medium  | 
  | Oh, God! ‡  |  Larry Gelbart  | 
  | The Spy Who Loved Me  |  Christopher Wood, and Richard Maibaum  | 
  | Semi-Tough  |  Walter Bernstein  | 
  | Best Comedy Written Directly for the Screen  | 
  | Annie Hall  |  Woody Allen and Marshall Brickman  | 
  | Star Wars  |  George Lucas  | 
  | Slap Shot  |  Nancy Dowd  | 
  | The Goodbye Girl  |  Neil Simon  | 
  1978 (31st)[32]  |  Best Comedy Adapted from Another Medium  | 
  | Heaven Can Wait ‡  |  Elaine May, and Warren Beatty  | 
  | California Suite ‡  |  Neil Simon  | 
  | Same Time, Next Year ‡  |  Bernard Slade  | 
  | Superman  |  Mario Puzo, David Newman, Leslie Newman, and Robert Benton  | 
  | Who Is Killing the Great Chefs of Europe?  |  Peter Stone  | 
  | Best Comedy Written Directly for the Screen  | 
  | Movie Movie  |   Larry Gelbart and Sheldon Keller  | 
  | A Wedding  |  John Considine, Patricia Resnick, Allan F. Nicholls, and Robert Altman  | 
  | Animal House  |  Harold Ramis, Douglas Kenney, and Chris Miller  | 
  | House Calls  |  Max Shulman, Julius J. Epstein, Alan Mandel, and Charles Shyer  | 
  | Once in Paris...  |  Frank D. Gilroy  | 
  1979 (32nd)[33]  |  Best Comedy Adapted from Another Medium  | 
  | Being There  |  Jerzy Kosinski  | 
  | Starting Over  |  James L. Brooks  | 
  | A Little Romance ‡  |  Allan Burns  | 
  | Best Comedy Written Directly for the Screen  | 
  | Breaking Away †  |   Steve Tesich   | 
  | 10  |  Blake Edwards  | 
  | Manhattan ‡  |  Woody Allen, and Marshall Brickman  |